Go back
Fermi's Paradox

Fermi's Paradox

Debates

i
Deracinated

Sydney

Joined
29 Jan 04
Moves
103056
Clock
11 May 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Sorry if this has been covered before (I'm a newcomer here), but Fermi's Paradox - is there a resolution?

Brother Edwin
7 edits

The moral highground

Joined
06 May 04
Moves
34658
Clock
11 May 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Plese explain for those of us who dont know what it is.

i
Deracinated

Sydney

Joined
29 Jan 04
Moves
103056
Clock
11 May 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

OK. If there's intelligent extraterrestrial life out there, where is it? Given enough time and a certain level of technology, the colonisation of the galaxy is a given. So where are they?

A brief internet wander might be in order to fully acquaint yourselves with the impact of this statement.

(Think stellar engineering, von neumann swarms).

f

Netherlands

Joined
09 Sep 03
Moves
4786
Clock
11 May 04
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by ivangrice
OK. If there's intelligent extraterrestrial life out there, where is it? Given enough time and a certain level of technology, the colonisation of the galaxy is a given. So where are they?

A brief internet wander might be in order t ...[text shortened]... his statement.

(Think stellar engineering, von neumann swarms).
One explanation that seems rather plausible to me is that development of technology always increases the internal tension in a civilization to a degree that it will cause the (self)destruction of that civilization. Not a nice view but worth looking at.

Fjord

DD

Joined
23 Apr 04
Moves
746
Clock
12 May 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Well, there are time and space limits (depending on where the aliens come from and when their habitat was formed) to intersolar contact. Stars are pretty far apart.

f

Netherlands

Joined
09 Sep 03
Moves
4786
Clock
12 May 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Dissident Dan
Well, there are time and space limits (depending on where the aliens come from and when their habitat was formed) to intersolar contact. Stars are pretty far apart.
Maybe! But after reading this interview you may change your mind.

http://www.astrobio.net/news/modules.php?op=modload&name=News&file=article&sid=939&mode=thread&order=0&thold=0

Fjord

j
Top Gun

Angels 20

Joined
27 Aug 03
Moves
10670
Clock
13 May 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Try reading 'Space' by Stephen Baxter, it's all about this very thing. He suggests several solutions, but it's been a while since I read it and I can't remember any of them now. Sorry

S
BentnevolentDictater

x10,y45,z-88,t3.1415

Joined
26 Jan 03
Moves
1644
Clock
15 May 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by ivangrice
Sorry if this has been covered before (I'm a newcomer here), but Fermi's Paradox - is there a resolution?
Welcome to RHP Ivan.

We have discussed this before. The discussion has always come down to "Drakes equation." It boils down to the fact that if half the stars in our galaxy have planets, there are probably about a hundred civilizations equal to ours floating about in the milky way. Give a billion or take nintey-nine.

How many Stars have planets? How many planets exist in the "Life" zones? How many of these develop life? How often does life evolve to intelligence? How many of these develop technology? How many technological civilizations can escape their world or develop technology sufficient to communicate with us?

A lot of guess work.

Personally.. seeing how pernicious life is on earth... I believe we are one of tens of thousands of civilizations. I also don't think "warp speed" is possible. We are alone. Ten thousand civilizations spread amongst the stars of our galaxy... is the same ratio as being one of two people on earth and hoping to make contact by walking at random and yelling out loud.

shavixmir
Lord

Sewers of Holland

Joined
31 Jan 04
Moves
89778
Clock
16 May 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

I'm forever praying to everyone elses god ('cause I don't have one for myself) that my true parents are aliens and that they'll come and take me away from this decripid rock.

But, if I was an alien I'd avoid earth with a 2 lightyear barge pole. Let's be honest: Earth is a shit-hole just waiting to implode.
Unless I was a teenage alien, then I'd come down here and leave crop circles...just to fuck with everyone's minds.

Brother Edwin
7 edits

The moral highground

Joined
06 May 04
Moves
34658
Clock
16 May 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

I dont know if Earth is really a s*it hole. Look at all the charaty workers. If you fell over in the street I am sure people would help. Also if you live in the West you have free education and get enouth food to surrvive.

j
Top Gun

Angels 20

Joined
27 Aug 03
Moves
10670
Clock
16 May 04
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Yes, but one would hope that an alien nation of sufficient advancement (is that a real word, or did i just make it up?) would be enlightened enough to not need aid workers, and would possibly be alarmed by what we need them for.
For another example from literature, see Iain M Banks' Culture books. Especially the novelette in 'The State of The Art' collection. In that the Culture, a large, almost utopic (another made up word?) civilisation, do visit the Earth covertly and decided it's to screwed up for them to Contact. I'd tend to agree with them.

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.