Go back
Florida law to ban …

Florida law to ban …

Debates

1 edit

Universities from teaching general courses “with a curriculum based on unproven, theoretical or exploratory content.” So, teaching physics courses about dark matter and dark energy are prohibited. As would courses about evolution and relativity have been banned before the theories had been proven. So, how the hell are students supposed to learn how to do research and test theories if they don’t hear any unproven theories?? Not in Florida, obviously!

https://us.cnn.com/2023/02/24/politics/ron-desantis-florida-universities-gender-studies/index.html


@moonbus said
Universities from teaching general courses “with a curriculum based on unproven, theoretical or exploratory content.” So, teaching physics courses about dark matter and dark energy are prohibited. As would courses about relativity have been banned before the theory had been proven. So, how the hell are students supposed to learn how to do research and test theories if they do ...[text shortened]...
https://us.cnn.com/2023/02/24/politics/ron-desantis-florida-universities-gender-studies/index.html
Solution:

Privatize all education.

Marked: SOLVED


@wajoma said
Solution:

Privatize all education.

Marked: SOLVED
If that law passes, I predict an exodus of good professors from Florida. The state university system will be left with only those teachers who can’t find work anywhere else.

1 edit

@moonbus said
Universities from teaching general courses “with a curriculum based on unproven, theoretical or exploratory content.” So, teaching physics courses about dark matter and dark energy are prohibited. As would courses about evolution and relativity have been banned before the theories had been proven. So, how the hell are students supposed to learn how to do research and test the ...[text shortened]...
https://us.cnn.com/2023/02/24/politics/ron-desantis-florida-universities-gender-studies/index.html
They have already heard of those unproven theories and I support not teaching about magic matter and magic energy unless it explains proven observations in a convenient way.
A good compromise would be to require the word "theory" after dark matter when written and spoken. I don't have a problem with MoND being followed by the word theory. Do they teach MoND theory at universities?
It isn't that I have a problem with the term dark matter as long as it is ordinary matter that cannot be seen. I just have a problem with a different kind of matter other than antimatter. Dark matter does not explain galaxy rotation observations. Why should it be taught at all?


@metal-brain said
They have already heard of those unproven theories and I support not teaching about magic matter and magic energy unless it explains proven observations in a convenient way.
A good compromise would be to require the word "theory" after dark matter when written and spoken. I don't have a problem with MoND being followed by the word theory. Do they teach MoND theory at un ...[text shortened]... timatter. Dark matter does not explain galaxy rotation observations. Why should it be taught at all?
There are millions of people in America who believe that evolution didn’t really happen. They believe it’s just a theory which hasn’t been proven yet. The Florida law would prohibit teaching it. There are millions of people in America who don’t believe there was a Big Bang about 14 billion years ago. They believe it’s just a theory which hasn’t been proven yet. The Florida law would prohibit teaching it. How is anyone supposed to prove a theory or disprove it, if it is not allowed to teach it before it has been proven? That’s what universities are for, isn’t it? Well, isn’t it? De Santis evidently thinks universities are point-scores in his big bid for the Oval Office. This is real bad for higher education. It puts Florida back to the dark ages, pre-Galileo, when “the Earth moves” was an unproven theory.


@moonbus said
There are millions of people in America who believe that evolution didn’t really happen. They believe it’s just a theory which hasn’t been proven yet. The Florida law would prohibit teaching it. There are millions of people in America who don’t believe there was a Big Bang about 14 billion years ago. They believe it’s just a theory which hasn’t been proven yet. The Florida la ...[text shortened]... . It puts Florida back to the dark ages, pre-Galileo, when “the Earth moves” was an unproven theory.
You used dark matter and dark energy as examples. Do universities teach MoND theory?

I think you need to determine if something is a theory or an hypothesis. I think you really meant to say hypothesis.


@metal-brain said
They have already heard of those unproven theories and I support not teaching about magic matter and magic energy unless it explains proven observations in a convenient way.
A good compromise would be to require the word "theory" after dark matter when written and spoken. I don't have a problem with MoND being followed by the word theory. Do they teach MoND theory at un ...[text shortened]... otation observations. Why should it be taught at all?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U5AaG_OIxPo
MOND doesn’t negate the need for dark matter.

And yes, obviously this theory is also taught at universities.


Evolution isn’t a theory.
Chickens 2000 years ago were different to the chickens we have today.
The average Dutch person is 30cm taller than the average Dutch person 100 years ago.

So everything evolves.
And that which doesn’t adapt dies out.

1 edit

@metal-brain said
You used dark matter and dark energy as examples. Do universities teach MoND theory?

I think you need to determine if something is a theory or an hypothesis. I think you really meant to say hypothesis.
Universities should not be prohibited from teaching ANY theory or hypothesis. The most fundamental freedom of all, more fundamental than all of the freedoms enshrined in the US Constitution and BoR, is the freedom to think. To think things which haven’t been proven. Prohibiting universities from teaching theories which are politically contentious is straight out of the Dark Ages when the Church prohibited Galileo from claiming that the Earth moves.

You asked whether MOND is taught. This answer your question?

https://ned.ipac.caltech.edu/level5/Sept01/Milgrom2/Milgrom_contents.html


@shavixmir said
Evolution isn’t a theory.
Chickens 2000 years ago were different to the chickens we have today.
The average Dutch person is 30cm taller than the average Dutch person 100 years ago.

So everything evolves.
And that which doesn’t adapt dies out.
Er, so why haven’t stupid people died out? 😳


@wajoma said
Solution:

Privatize all education.

Marked: SOLVED
So just like health care, only those who can pay for it have access. Killing education will destroy the U.S. global economy. Countries that understand and value education and research will advance. The US will quickly decline. No terrorists needed. Just people like you.


@phranny said
So just like health care, only those who can pay for it have access. Killing education will destroy the U.S. global economy. Countries that understand and value education and research will advance. The US will quickly decline. No terrorists needed. Just people like you.
Agreed. America’s great experiment in freedom will not be conquered from without. It is being legislated away from within.


@moonbus said
Er, so why haven’t stupid people died out? 😳
It’s a slow process.

And trailer parks keep churning out retarded republicans.


@shavixmir said
It’s a slow process.

And trailer parks keep churning out retarded republicans.
Well, at least we know where they congregate, and trailers don’t fare well in tornadoes. Yeah! Climate change! Let’s have more tornadoes! 😆


@moonbus

So instead of talking about the ban on gender studies and classes that get the blacks angry and acting the fool... you change it to outer space crap?

Nice dodge 🙄