Go back
Great Ape Personhood

Great Ape Personhood

Debates

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Bosse de Nage
Nope, haven't read that one. Any good? I've read some brilliant and not-so-brilliant stuff by Self; How the Dead Live was pretty funny.

I don't see the absurdity of attributing apes personhood. It doesn't equate with treating them as people--"How do you do, Mr Greystoke, please take your seat"--but rather giving them protective legal status. ...[text shortened]... e humanity it has squandered in its cruel & dubious pursuits.

Time for a cup of tea.
I read that, whereas chimps, orang-utans, gibbons (and maybe even dolphins) can recognize themselves in a mirror, gorillas cannot. That is, if you put, say, a red spot on the forehead of an adult great ape, and then show them the result in a mirror, all apes except gorillas will start exploring their foreheads with their fingers. So, given that self-concsciousness is a key component of personhood, maybe gorillas are not so much persons as other apes are.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Pawnokeyhole
So, given that self-concsciousness is a key component of personhood, maybe gorillas are not so much persons as other apes are.
Either that or they're self-effacing to the extreme. (I think you have a good point).