Go back
ID vs. Evolution The Best Summary

ID vs. Evolution The Best Summary

Debates

p

Joined
05 Jun 06
Moves
9180
Clock
28 May 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

The movie Flock of Dodos was a great movie. I just saw it and it evaluates situation of the debate. I thought that is was pretty much unbiased but I'm me right. If anyone else has seen this movie feedback would be great. Interesting questions and accurate summaries. It is on showtime right now under documentaries, and please don't slam it without watching it.

S

Joined
19 Nov 03
Moves
31382
Clock
28 May 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by pizzintea
The movie Flock of Dodos was a great movie. I just saw it and it evaluates situation of the debate. I thought that is was pretty much unbiased but I'm me right. If anyone else has seen this movie feedback would be great. Interesting questions and accurate summaries. It is on showtime right now under documentaries, and please don't slam it without watching it.
Perhaps you could lay out some of the points it makes, or provide links?

p

Joined
05 Jun 06
Moves
9180
Clock
28 May 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

That is a good idea. Sorry Don't post much.

"Flock of Dodos humorously examines the debate between proponents of the concept of intelligent design and the scientific establishment that supports evolution."

"The film attempts to determine who the real "dodos" are in a constantly evolving world: the scientists who are failing to promote evolution as a scientifically accepted fact, the intelligent design advocates, or the American public who get fooled by the salesmanship of the Discovery Institute."

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flock_of_Dodos

I enjoyed the movie because it was comical as well as informative. It addresses important issues.

twhitehead

Cape Town

Joined
14 Apr 05
Moves
52945
Clock
28 May 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by pizzintea
.... a great movie. I thought that is was pretty much unbiased .....
If its unbiased then it is a lousy movie. Unless it points out that evolution is science and ID is hogwash then it is a lousy movie.

p

Joined
05 Jun 06
Moves
9180
Clock
28 May 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

So much for watching it before you slam it. Anyway it does that but not in those terms.

S

Joined
19 Nov 03
Moves
31382
Clock
28 May 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by pizzintea
So much for watching it before you slam it. Anyway it does that but not in those terms.
Whilst I advocate an unbiased approach to things, the nature of the two topics is not one which should come under debate in the pursuit of whether one is more accurate, or whether ID should be taught in schools etc. The fact of the matter is that ID is not falsifiable, scientific, of natural origin or empirically testable, as such it has no place in the academic world. From your description I'm sure the film has some merit as an amusing documentary analysing the common perception of the war between these two opposing forces. However, whilst I'm not going to slam the movie like twhitehead has, I'm in agreement with him on the state of play. ID should be ridiculed if it attempts to enter the academic arena, people are free to hold it as a personal belief, but the notion that it is in any way comparable with evolution is ridiculous.

p

Joined
05 Jun 06
Moves
9180
Clock
28 May 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

I was just trying to get people to watch the movie. It is pro evolution. Ok??? They explain how a debate even came to be. Teach the controversy. That nice catch phrase and a hundred more are developed by this company. They explain what is happening today. Evolutionists don't create catch phrases and for the general public there is too much information around to understand an explanation so a trend is leaning toward ID for a simple answer to a complicated world. Don't watch the movie. Doesn't matter to me.

S

Joined
19 Nov 03
Moves
31382
Clock
28 May 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by pizzintea
I was just trying to get people to watch the movie. It is pro evolution. Ok??? They explain how a debate even came to be. Teach the controversy. That nice catch phrase and a hundred more are developed by this company. They explain what is happening today. Evolutionists don't create catch phrases and for the general public there is too much information arou ...[text shortened]... d ID for a simple answer to a complicated world. Don't watch the movie. Doesn't matter to me.
I'm not saying I wouldn't watch the movie, just commenting on the nature of its content, that's all.

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.