Go back
Iraqi Underground backed by Iran?

Iraqi Underground backed by Iran?

Debates

i

Joined
07 Apr 05
Moves
1226
Clock
14 Aug 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

The other day, soldiers stopped a truck that was carrying Irani weapons to the iraqi underground insurgency. I have long speculated that Iran may of been supporting the insurgency, but this may be a piece of evidence that proves it. Who here believes the insurgency may be backed by Iran. Keep in mind, the insurgents have stepped up there attacks in effectiveness.

shavixmir
Lord

Sewers of Holland

Joined
31 Jan 04
Moves
89787
Clock
14 Aug 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by iamroot
The other day, soldiers stopped a truck that was carrying Irani weapons to the iraqi underground insurgency. I have long speculated that Iran may of been supporting the insurgency, but this may be a piece of evidence that proves it. Who here believes the insurgency may be backed by Iran. Keep in mind, the insurgents have stepped up there attacks in effectiveness.
I thought you were on about a metro system!

I was seriously thinking...a subway in Baghdad...that's a bit optimistic, isn't it?

D

Joined
31 Jul 05
Moves
419
Clock
14 Aug 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by iamroot
The other day, soldiers stopped a truck that was carrying Irani weapons to the iraqi underground insurgency. I have long speculated that Iran may of been supporting the insurgency, but this may be a piece of evidence that proves it. Who here believes the insurgency may be backed by Iran. Keep in mind, the insurgents have stepped up there attacks in effectiveness.
😴

And let me guess, you find this reason to declare war and kill even more innocents simply because a country is helping another country earn freedom from invasion of a brutal force...

i

Felicific Forest

Joined
15 Dec 02
Moves
49429
Clock
14 Aug 05
4 edits
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by iamroot
The other day, soldiers stopped a truck that was carrying Irani weapons to the iraqi underground insurgency. I have long speculated that Iran may of been supporting the insurgency, but this may be a piece of evidence that proves it. Who h ...[text shortened]... nd, the insurgents have stepped up there attacks in effectiveness.
The Iranian government is supporting the Shiite faction in Iraq, also by supplying them with weapons. They themselves are shiites too. The situation in Iraq is a wonderful opportunity for them to realise their political dream and that is to become the regional super power, of course in due time in possession of nuclear arms, they think .....
Now that the Iraqi aspirations of becoming THE regional power are shattered, and a serious rival is eliminated on the road to the Iranian goal, the Iranians think it is a good idea to redouble their efforts.

i

Joined
07 Apr 05
Moves
1226
Clock
14 Aug 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by DeadBeSwallowed
😴

And let me guess, you find this reason to declare war and kill even more innocents simply because a country is helping another country earn freedom from invasion of a brutal force...
America has already invaded Iraq and won. There is no changing this now. So any opposition from Iran would not be to protect the insurgency, but just to simply kill americans, or even worst, to create unrest.


And, on the same note: I was part of the initial invasion force into Iraq, and having been stationed at Camp Liberty, Iraq for 12 months, I can tell you that there may of been a small insurgency, but most of the citizens there we not unhappy to see coaliton troops.

D

Joined
31 Jul 05
Moves
419
Clock
14 Aug 05
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by iamroot
America has already invaded Iraq and won. There is no changing this now. So any opposition from Iran would not be to protect the insurgency, but just to simply kill americans, or even worst, to create unrest.


And, on the same note: ...[text shortened]... most of the citizens there we not unhappy to see coaliton troops.
I guess the rebels during the war of independance fought pointlessly, just increased unrest and terrorism, just wanted to kill Brits for no reason, as Britain was already in their country, fully invaded and all.

no1marauder
Naturally Right

Somewhere Else

Joined
22 Jun 04
Moves
42677
Clock
14 Aug 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Good fer the Iranians! When the Soviets invaded and occupied Afghanistan, the US government sent weapons to the Afghan rebels. The Iranians would have even greater justification to send arms to the Iraqi insurgency; after all, Iraq is right next store to Iran and US troops there are far more of a threat to Iran than Soviet troops in Afghanistan were to the US.

And that "small" insurgency gets rolling on, don't it? Over 1900 US dead and rising every day. Last week was the fourth worst for US troops killed in combat since the start of the war and the military says attacks against US troops have doubled in frequency since the start of the year. Time to bring the boys and girls home; if the Iranians benefit because of the US government's stupid policies, I say: "GOOD FER THE IRANIANS"!

x
Incroyant

tinyurl.com/ksdwu

Joined
22 Sep 04
Moves
4728
Clock
14 Aug 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by no1marauder
Good fer the Iranians! When the Soviets invaded and occupied Afghanistan, the US government sent weapons to the Afghan rebels. The Iranians would have even greater justification to send arms to the Iraqi insurgency; after all, Iraq is right next store to Iran and US troops there are far more of a threat to Iran than Soviet troops in Afghanistan ...[text shortened]... nians benefit because of the US government's stupid policies, I say: "GOOD FER THE IRANIANS"!
http://piv.pivpiv.dk/

i

Joined
07 Apr 05
Moves
1226
Clock
14 Aug 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by DeadBeSwallowed
I guess the rebels during the war of independance fought pointlessly, just increased unrest and terrorism, just wanted to kill Brits for no reason, as Britain was already in their country, fully invaded and all.
no, your logic incorrect. WIth the analogy of relating this to the american revolution, the iranians should be considered the french, who, by the way, got into the war for their own personal gain.

D

Joined
31 Jul 05
Moves
419
Clock
15 Aug 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by iamroot
no, your logic incorrect. WIth the analogy of relating this to the american revolution, the iranians should be considered the french, who, by the way, got into the war for their own personal gain.
Of course Iran is in this for themselves aswell, do you think Iran wants a USA outpost right next door to their country? Especially when Bush made it clear they are the next victims on the "war on terror". The Iranians are defending themselves and helping the Iraqis win freedom too, two birds with one stone, not only that, through democratic means, the Iranians managed to get a pro-Iranian president voted by the people of Iraq, Iran is playing a smart game and the Iraqis support them...

i

Joined
07 Apr 05
Moves
1226
Clock
15 Aug 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Well tell me this. Do you think that Iraq would be happier in the way they are going now, or happier underneath Saddam? Keep in mind that America will be leaving Iraq to fend for themselves in the future. I can tell you, of the people I talked to in Iraq most people were very happy when coalition troops ousted Saddam. But on the otherhand, who would dare spit and yell at an American that is carrying an M16.


One other thing to think about: Saddam ruled his regime with the fear. He controlled people by making them fear what he would do to them if they resisted. After all the terrorists popped up in Iraq, not just against the troops, but against each other as well(shiites vs. the sunni, etc), I am starting to think that maybe Saddam didn't rule that way because he wanted to, but because he had too. Sometimes fear is the only thing that will keep peace. Maybe, he was a hard ruler because if he wasn't, the people in Iraq would kill one another. When your ruler is starving you and your family out, you do as he says.


I think they should do a poll, only for Iraqis, asking whether they feel safer under coalition protection, or under Saddam's regime. The poll should be completely anonymous. Also, we should ask them if they think that the country may prosper more, now that Saddam is gone.

i

Joined
07 Apr 05
Moves
1226
Clock
19 Aug 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

hmmm no response on asking the Iraqis what they think? It seems like the only solution to the problem, since europeans think that no one but them have the right to an opinion, and americans think that everyone has a right to an opinion, as long as you keep it to yourself.

AThousandYoung
1st Dan TKD Kukkiwon

tinyurl.com/2te6yzdu

Joined
23 Aug 04
Moves
26758
Clock
19 Aug 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by iamroot
hmmm no response on asking the Iraqis what they think? It seems like the only solution to the problem, since europeans think that no one but them have the right to an opinion, and americans think that everyone has a right to an opinion, as long as you keep it to yourself.
In theory, I absolutely favor asking the Iraqis what they think. In practice however I don't think they would give honest answers and I suspect the pollers may not report the responses honestly either.

It's a tough call.

Bosse de Nage
Zellulärer Automat

Spiel des Lebens

Joined
27 Jan 05
Moves
90892
Clock
19 Aug 05
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by iamroot

And, on the same note: I was part of the initial invasion force into Iraq, and having been stationed at Camp Liberty, Iraq for 12 months, I can tell you that there may of been a small insurgency, but most of the citizens there we not unhappy to see coaliton troops.
You're the first person I've encountered with first-hand experience of Iraq. Where is Camp Liberty? What was your function? How did the citizens express their happiness at your presence?

Does the ongoing mayhem in Iraq not detract from your statement that your side won?

i

Joined
07 Apr 05
Moves
1226
Clock
21 Aug 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Camp Liberty is basically the worlds biggest trailer park :-P We lived in trailers that stretched about as far as you could see, with concrete dividers to protect the trailers from mortar.

Contrary to what people in this thread think of me, i serve as a counterintelligence agent. But, there you spend about 15% of your time on duty, and 85% of your time playing xbox.

How did the people react? When we first came in, they acted...desperately overjoyed. There was also alot of rioting too... I guess people were enjoying there newfound freedom. I did not have much interaction with the people at first, i was "in the rear with the gear", as you would hear in full metal jacket. after about a month there, all they wanted to do was sell you something.

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.