Go back
Italian Government Without Politicians

Italian Government Without Politicians

Debates

spruce112358
It's All A Joke

Joined
23 Oct 04
Moves
4402
Clock
16 Nov 11
Vote Up
Vote Down

http://news.yahoo.com/monti-forms-italian-government-123451783.html

The new Italian premier has announced "that the non-presence of politicians in the government would help (the government)."

What do you think? Would all governments be better off without politicians?

Perhaps Italy just needs a strenuous regime of diet and exercise -- and maybe Monti is just the guy to do it.

K

Germany

Joined
27 Oct 08
Moves
3118
Clock
16 Nov 11
Vote Up
Vote Down

Time will tell. Anyway, Dutch governments tend to include a mixture of politicians and non-politicians, so I'm not new to the idea.

finnegan
GENS UNA SUMUS

Joined
25 Jun 06
Moves
64930
Clock
17 Nov 11
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by spruce112358
http://news.yahoo.com/monti-forms-italian-government-123451783.html

The new Italian premier has announced "that the non-presence of politicians in the government would help (the government)."

What do you think? Would all governments be better off without politicians?

Perhaps Italy just needs a strenuous regime of diet and exercise -- and maybe Monti is just the guy to do it.
Another piece of blather. Government is by definition a political job. The premier is by definition a politican and so are his cabinet. You can tell he is a politician by the way he boasts about not being a politican. Blather! What he and they are not is elected.

g

Pepperland

Joined
30 May 07
Moves
12892
Clock
17 Nov 11
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by finnegan
Another piece of blather. Government is by definition a political job. The premier is by definition a politican and so are his cabinet. You can tell he is a politician by the way he boasts about not being a politican. Blather! What he and they are not is elected.
You can tell he is a politician by the way he boasts about not being a politican

Some funny logic here. well, anyway, surely you must understand that the OP, by referring to the new Italian government being without politicians, means simply that it will consist of technocrats as opposed to creatures of the party political machine.

w

Joined
02 Jan 06
Moves
12857
Clock
17 Nov 11
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by spruce112358
http://news.yahoo.com/monti-forms-italian-government-123451783.html

The new Italian premier has announced "that the non-presence of politicians in the government would help (the government)."

What do you think? Would all governments be better off without politicians?

Perhaps Italy just needs a strenuous regime of diet and exercise -- and maybe Monti is just the guy to do it.
I would like to see it done like Jury duty. You get a letter in the mail and get a week off work to do some legislat'in!!

finnegan
GENS UNA SUMUS

Joined
25 Jun 06
Moves
64930
Clock
17 Nov 11
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by generalissimo
[b]You can tell he is a politician by the way he boasts about not being a politican

Some funny logic here. well, anyway, surely you must understand that the OP, by referring to the new Italian government being without politicians, means simply that it will consist of technocrats as opposed to creatures of the party political machine.[/b]
What's a "Technocrat" when it's at home? Who are they accountable to?

Politicians are elected not only for status and to hand out favours, but also with responsibilities and if they are not prepared to carry these out they should be ejected from office and fresh elections held.

In English local government (unlike Parliament of course) an elected Council that fails to pass a responsible budget within its resources is held liable for the resulting costs - ie the local politicans making up the Council are personally liable. The most entertaining example was Dame Shirley Porter, one time leader of Westminster Council, who was "surcharged" £35m and skipped the country to Israel to sit on her wealth from Tesco.

My point is that far from an attack on democracy from outside, this represents a failure of democracy internally to Italy. For a country that has produced so many excellent political thinkers this is a sad state of affairs.

g

Pepperland

Joined
30 May 07
Moves
12892
Clock
17 Nov 11
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by finnegan
What's a "Technocrat" when it's at home? Who are they accountable to?

Politicians are elected not only for status and to hand out favours, but also with responsibilities and if they are not prepared to carry these out they should be ejected from office and fresh elections held.

In English local government (unlike Parliament of course) an elected Cou ...[text shortened]... try that has produced so many excellent political thinkers this is a sad state of affairs.
Well, Im not necessarily congratulating Italy for its failures or welcoming the relinquishment of conventional democratic mechanisms of accountability in the country- my point was merely that there is salient difference between the current Italian government and the one which preceded it, in the sense that the current one isn't headed by career politicians preoccupied with opinion polls and party political point-scoring or anything of the sort.

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.