06 Apr '10 20:55>
Why wasn't he executed as a traitor when he came back from the Soviet Union?
Originally posted by joneschr"In fact, early on there were assertions that Oswald was a federal undercover agent. According to a biographical sketch of Waggoner Carr, the Texas Attorney General who led the investigation in Texas into the assassination and worked with the Warren Commission, “Carr testified that Lee Harvey Oswald was working as an undercover agent for the Federal Bureau of Investigation and was receiving $200 a month from September 1962 until his death in November, 1963. However, the Warren Commission preferred to believe J. Edgar Hoover, who denied Carr’s affirmations.”
True, though, to change the question a little - why wasn't he at least arrested and tried?
You'd think a discharged marine that went to the soviets offering to spill the beans on his training would have gotten more notice.
Originally posted by AThousandYoungThe answer is:
Why wasn't he executed as a traitor when he came back from the Soviet Union?
Originally posted by zeeblebotWell, at least they knew: a couple quotes from wikipedia:
maybe the US just wanted to track him for a while. or maybe they didn't know.
Even before November 22, 1963, Oswald received a small measure of national notoriety in the U.S. press as an American who had defected to the U.S.S.R. and returned.
When the Navy Department learned of <his attempt to communicate with the soviets>, it changed Oswald's Marine Corps discharge from "hardship/honorable" to "undesirable".
Originally posted by sh76No, I'm not a conspiracy kinda guy.
The answer is:
Because the US doesn't execute people without trying them first and the US authorities were probably unaware of his previous actions in the USSR at the time. Hindsight is 20/20; but at the time, Oswald was a very small fish.
I'm not sure if you're alluding to this, but I'll also tell you what the answer is NOT:
Oswald was a CIA double ...[text shortened]... trial complex/ KGB/ Fidel Castro/ Cuban Mob/ Various other Mobs all conspired to murder JFK.
Originally posted by zeeblebotAs soon as he arrived in the Soviet Union he offered to the soviets to disclose confidential information he acquired while training as a radar operator in the marines.
it wasn't illegal to travel to the USSR, was it? on what basis would they execute him?
Originally posted by joneschryeah, but did the US know that at the time?
As soon as he arrived in the Soviet Union he offered to the soviets to disclose confidential information he acquired while training as a radar operator in the marines.
So, I guess the basis would be treason.
Originally posted by zeeblebotAs of November, 1959, they knew. And strangely enough, it really was Oswald that volunteered the information -- when trying to renounce his U.S. citizenship.
yeah, but did the US know that at the time?
i'm guessing that neither the Soviets nor Oswald volunteered that.
that he had voluntarily stated to unnamed Soviet officials ... he would make known to them such information concerning the Marine corps and his specialty...