Go back
let's replace a 4-star general...

let's replace a 4-star general...

Debates

w

Joined
20 Oct 06
Moves
9627
Clock
21d
Vote Up
Vote Down

The new secretary of defense under Trump's administration will be the weekend co-host of Fox and friends.

Not a joke.

He has other things in his resume but this seems like a poor choice considering that he's been a talking head with zero responsibility in leadership for the last 10 years.

Cliff Mashburn

Joined
09 Jan 22
Moves
1139
Clock
21d

@wildgrass said
The new secretary of defense under Trump's administration will be the weekend co-host of Fox and friends.

Not a joke.

He has other things in his resume but this seems like a poor choice considering that he's been a talking head with zero responsibility in leadership for the last 10 years.
He's an Army major with combat experience, served in two wars, that's good enough for me.

s
Fast and Curious

slatington, pa, usa

Joined
28 Dec 04
Moves
53321
Clock
21d

@Cliff-Mashburn
Right, a MAJOR, where it goes, second lieutenant, first lieutenant, captain, major, LIGHT colonel, full colonel, then lowest general, brigadier, Major General, lieutenant general, and 4 star general. So six levels lower than the top and I don't suppose you did military duty but I did, four years and I saw what those levels did.
A major might have duty over a couple hundred dudes but that would be it, ZERO upper rank involvement so he might as well be an Uber driver for the experience needed to be the top dog in our national defense.
So tell me, what military did YOU serve in?

w

Joined
20 Oct 06
Moves
9627
Clock
21d

@Cliff-Mashburn said
He's an Army major with combat experience, served in two wars, that's good enough for me.
Imagine that, a major telling the generals what to do. They'll love it.

All he had to do to get the job was retire from the army and spend 10 years on the boob tube saying whatever made trump happy.

Lionel Hutz
It's me: Seitse

Buenos Aires

Joined
27 Sep 20
Moves
680
Clock
21d

Dude's fit, loves the troops, communication skills are 10/10, and has "Deus Vult" tattooed on his massive bicep.

The big wigs are going to melt. Hilarity shall ensue. Can't wait! πŸ˜€

boonon

Joined
30 Dec 04
Moves
97288
Clock
21d

@sonhouse said
@Cliff-Mashburn
Right, a MAJOR, where it goes, second lieutenant, first lieutenant, captain, major, LIGHT colonel, full colonel, then lowest general, brigadier, Major General, lieutenant general, and 4 star general. So six levels lower than the top and I don't suppose you did military duty but I did, four years and I saw what those levels did.
A major might have duty over ...[text shortened]... ience needed to be the top dog in our national defense.
So tell me, what military did YOU serve in?
You were also an astronaut, correct?

Ponderable
chemist

Linkenheim

Joined
22 Apr 05
Moves
669113
Clock
21d

Would this be a Forum to debate things I would venture to put forward a thesis:

It can be beneficial for the secretary of defence not to have been an officer.

I would argue, that the defnese secretary has Generals on the side to take care of military matters. If the secretary does listen there is a good chance that they get very good information to act on in all things military.
The non-officer person would at least have the opportunity to look through "pet projects" and put a new frame around those.

Ponderable
chemist

Linkenheim

Joined
22 Apr 05
Moves
669113
Clock
21d

@sonhouse said
@Cliff-Mashburn
Right, a MAJOR, where it goes, second lieutenant, first lieutenant, captain, major, LIGHT colonel, full colonel, then lowest general, brigadier, Major General, lieutenant general, and 4 star general. So six levels lower than the top and I don't suppose you did military duty but I did, four years and I saw what those levels did.
A major might have duty over ...[text shortened]... ience needed to be the top dog in our national defense.
So tell me, what military did YOU serve in?
In fact there have been secretaries of defnce who left the Army with lower ranks before.

shavixmir
Lord

Sewers of Holland

Joined
31 Jan 04
Moves
89693
Clock
21d

Competence is more important than rank.
And we can trust trump to fill every post with the most attrocious of arse lickers, lacking any form of competence uther than their ability to rim.

w

Joined
20 Oct 06
Moves
9627
Clock
21d

@Ponderable said
Would this be a Forum to debate things I would venture to put forward a thesis:

It can be beneficial for the secretary of defence not to have been an officer.

I would argue, that the defnese secretary has Generals on the side to take care of military matters. If the secretary does listen there is a good chance that they get very good information to act on in all thin ...[text shortened]... would at least have the opportunity to look through "pet projects" and put a new frame around those.
I would argue that it is his role as a shock jock entertainer that disqualify him for a job that requires a high level of professionalism, organization, and discretion.

w

Joined
20 Oct 06
Moves
9627
Clock
21d

@Lionel-Hutz said
Dude's fit, loves the troops, communication skills are 10/10, and has "Deus Vult" tattooed on his massive bicep.

The big wigs are going to melt. Hilarity shall ensue. Can't wait! πŸ˜€
Lol a tattoo is a job qualification. Base conservatives have fallen so low.

Ponderable
chemist

Linkenheim

Joined
22 Apr 05
Moves
669113
Clock
21d

@wildgrass

In fact I am not convinced that the nominatde guy is such a good choice.

I was just taking up the general thesis that a 4*-General would be per se a better choice than anyone who did not attain the rank.

w

Joined
20 Oct 06
Moves
9627
Clock
21d

@Ponderable said
@wildgrass

In fact I am not convinced that the nominatde guy is such a good choice.

I was just taking up the general thesis that a 4*-General would be per se a better choice than anyone who did not attain the rank.
Sure, I agree. Usually job hirings rely on more than one qualification.

This guy's professional life is defined by his role in the entertainment industry, not his military career.

no1marauder
Naturally Right

Somewhere Else

Joined
22 Jun 04
Moves
42677
Clock
21d

@wildgrass said
The new secretary of defense under Trump's administration will be the weekend co-host of Fox and friends.

Not a joke.

He has other things in his resume but this seems like a poor choice considering that he's been a talking head with zero responsibility in leadership for the last 10 years.
(Shrug) Cabinet positions are flunkies of the President and his choices should be confirmed unless they are grossly incompetent or corrupt.

moonbus
Über-Nerd (emeritus)

Joined
31 May 12
Moves
8703
Clock
21d

@no1marauder said
(Shrug) Cabinet positions are flunkies of the President and his choices should be confirmed unless they are grossly incompetent or corrupt.
So it'll be Hannity for Dept. of State, right ?

James Dobson for HEW ...

Might be a good time to stock up yer bomb shelter. Don't forget lots of GOYA BEANS !

https://fabioparasecoli.com/beans-battles-goya-the-trumps-and-the-power-of-food/

πŸ˜†

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.