Go back
Male trans athletes

Male trans athletes

Debates

3 edits
Vote Up
Vote Down

Debates about trans athletes usually focus on trans women.

But....if a woman transitions to a man, receives hormones that increases physical attributes and can now win against men in sports....is that cheating? Because the trans man is receiving performance enhancing drugs, something cis men would get banned for.

1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

@vivify said
Debates about trans athletes usually focus on trans women.

But....if a woman transitions to a man, receives hormones that increases physical attributes and can now win against men in sports....is that cheating? Because the trans man is receiving performance enhancing drugs, something cis men would get banned for.
Of course it is cheating. Other men don't get to take those hormones (testosterone?)
If you want to run with the men, then you run by the men's rules. Simple.

Same with transwomen. Officials must accept their bodies just as they are. No need to force them to lower their testosterone

Vote Up
Vote Down

@vivify said
Debates about trans athletes usually focus on trans women.

But....if a woman transitions to a man, receives hormones that increases physical attributes and can now win against men in sports....is that cheating? Because the trans man is receiving performance enhancing drugs, something cis men would get banned for.
They set max hormone levels for many sports. I'm not sure if someone who is naturally below the max would be allowed to supplement or how they would even know.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@vivify said
Debates about trans athletes usually focus on trans women.

But....if a woman transitions to a man, receives hormones that increases physical attributes and can now win against men in sports....is that cheating? Because the trans man is receiving performance enhancing drugs, something cis men would get banned for.
Drugs aside, I think we can stipulate that if a girl does (all the stuff) to be a man, that the real man will still prevail over a woman-who-calls-herself-a-man in any of the subject sports.

Vivify, since you fellers will never stop coming, I can see this issue moving into prosthetics being allowed by competitors during competition. Sad.

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.