Go back
Must you have a uterus to have a valid opinion on abortion?

Must you have a uterus to have a valid opinion on abortion?

Debates

Vote Up
1
Vote Down
-4

Must one have a uterus to have a valid opinion on abortion?

I ask this because I encountered someone who threw this at me the other day.

What say you?

1 edit
Vote Up
3
Vote Down
-1
Vote Up
4
Vote Down

Originally posted by @whodey
Must one have a uterus to have a valid opinion on abortion?

I ask this because I encountered someone who threw this at me the other day.

What say you?
No.

A functioning brain, however, is a requirement. And this then creates an issue, Whodey.

Vote Up
Vote Down
-2

The post that was quoted here has been removed
But SCOTUS decides everything for everyone.

So considering this, should only women be deciding court rulings like Roe vs. Wade?

1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down
-2

Originally posted by @great-king-rat
No.

A functioning brain, however, is a requirement. And this then creates an issue, Whodey.
The woman I was talking to was a Leftist feminist and said that I had no right to comment on abortion because I was a male, thus attempting to silence me.

I reckon since Facebook or Youtube could not censor my speech at the time, she would do it for me.

Are you saying then that she was an idiot or did she have a point?

Vote Up
2
Vote Down

Originally posted by @whodey
The woman I was talking to was a Leftist feminist and said that I had no right to comment on abortion because I was a male, thus attempting to silence me.

I reckon since Facebook or Youtube could not censor my speech at the time, she would do it for me.

Are you saying then that she was an idiot or did she have a point?
What qualifications do you have that you believe entitle you to make binding decisions on her uterus?

Vote Up
5
Vote Down
-1

Originally posted by @whodey
Must one have a uterus to have a valid opinion on abortion?

I ask this because I encountered someone who threw this at me the other day.

What say you?
No, you can have a valid opinion about it without a uterus.

What you can’t do is tell a woman what she can or cannot do to her own body and everything internally attached to it.

Her body, her choice.
You can have your valid opinion though, no worries.

Vote Up
4
Vote Down
-1

Originally posted by @whodey
The woman I was talking to was a Leftist feminist and said that I had no right to comment on abortion because I was a male, thus attempting to silence me.

I reckon since Facebook or Youtube could not censor my speech at the time, she would do it for me.

Are you saying then that she was an idiot or did she have a point?
No, she doesn’t have a valid point.
But, ironically, you are still a bloody idiot.

Vote Up
Vote Down
-1

Is it right for someone who has a Siamese Twin to kill their twin? "My body my choice" right?

Vote Up
1
Vote Down

Originally posted by @whodey
The woman I was talking to was a Leftist feminist and said that I had no right to comment on abortion because I was a male, thus attempting to silence me.

I reckon since Facebook or Youtube could not censor my speech at the time, she would do it for me.

Are you saying then that she was an idiot or did she have a point?
She was an idiot.

Any more questions?

Vote Up
Vote Down
-3
Vote Up
1
Vote Down

Originally posted by @whodey
Must one have a uterus to have a valid opinion on abortion?

I ask this because I encountered someone who threw this at me the other day.

What say you?
I don't know what's necessary for you to have a valid opinion on abortion, but my guess is a uterus won't help.

Vote Up
3
Vote Down
-1
1 edit
Vote Up
1
Vote Down
-1

Originally posted by @whodey
Must one have a uterus to have a valid opinion on abortion?

I ask this because I encountered someone who threw this at me the other day.

What say you?
Since the vast majority of lawmakers and judges deciding abortion issues are men, your question seems rather silly. 😞

Vote Up
Vote Down