Go back
New York judge let's cop attackers out with no bail.

New York judge let's cop attackers out with no bail.

Debates


The video is brutal, he's lucky the three of them didn't kill him.
I looked up the judge, the picture of him came as no surprise.
https://nypost.com/2023/11/16/metro/nyc-cop-attackers-released-without-bail-after-beating-up-nypd-officer/


@jj-adams said
The video is brutal, he's lucky the three of them didn't kill him.
I looked up the judge, the picture of him came as no surprise.
https://nypost.com/2023/11/16/metro/nyc-cop-attackers-released-without-bail-after-beating-up-nypd-officer/
"Two officers suffered minor injuries and were treated at the scene, police said."

https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/crime/thugs-brutally-attack-nypd-cop-who-asked-them-to-stop-smoking-at-subway-station/ar-AA1jXPYn

And according to the article you cited, the defendants had no prior criminal records.

Release without bail seems perfectly reasonable in this case.

1 edit

@no1marauder said
"Two officers suffered minor injuries and were treated at the scene, police said."

https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/crime/thugs-brutally-attack-nypd-cop-who-asked-them-to-stop-smoking-at-subway-station/ar-AA1jXPYn

And according to the article you cited, the defendants had no prior criminal records.

Release without bail seems perfectly reasonable in this case.
That's because the second cop intervened when they were beating the other cop up, three -on-one....if he hadn't come along they wouldn't have stopped.
No criminal records, so what?
Violently ganging up and attacking a cop deserves a lot more than catch and release.
If it was three whites beating up a black cop what do you think the judge's decision would have been?

1 edit

@jj-adams said
That's because the second cop intervened when they were beating the other cop up, three -on-one....if he hadn't come along they wouldn't have stopped.
No criminal records, so what?
Violently ganging up and attacking a cop deserves a lot more than catch and release.
If it was three whites beating up a black cop what do you think the judge's decision would have been?
I'm not interested in your usual racist take on events.

What may or may not have happened in a hypothetical future is irrelevant to bail decisions. Since the cop didn't even receive a "physical injury" according to the definition in the NY Penal Law (https://www.newyorkcriminalattorneyblog.com/new_york_physical_injury_assau_1/), in all likelihood these defendants will be offered plea bargains with no or minimal jail time and probation. That doesn't warrant pre-trial custody. Bail is for when there is a serious risk of flight not for added punishment before guilt is legally established.


@no1marauder said
I'm not interested in your usual racist take on events.

What may or may not have happened in a hypothetical future is irrelevant to bail decisions. Since the cop didn't even receive a "physical injury" according to the definition in the NY Penal Law (https://www.newyorkcriminalattorneyblog.com/new_york_physical_injury_assau_1/), in all likelihood these defendants will ...[text shortened]... when there is a serious risk of flight not for added punishment before guilt is legally established.
The article I posted didn't show the video, I figured you wouldn't watch it.
Take a look and tell me how harmless you think it was:
https://www.amren.com/news/2023/11/bronx-judge-frees-men-charged-with-beating-up-nypd-officer/

1 edit

@jj-adams said
The article I posted didn't show the video, I figured you wouldn't watch it.
Take a look and tell me how harmless you think it was:
https://www.amren.com/news/2023/11/bronx-judge-frees-men-charged-with-beating-up-nypd-officer/
I won't go to a blatantly racist site like American Renaissance.

Are you disputing your own cited article's report that the cop suffered only minor injuries and was treated at the scene?

EDIT: Oh sorry the New York Post didn't mention that inconvenient fact.


@no1marauder said
I won't go to a blatantly racist site like American Renaissance.

Are you disputing your own cited article's report that the cop suffered only minor injuries and was treated at the scene?
Are you trying to claim the video is fake?
Oh...that's right, you won't watch it.
Also if you've never been to Amren how do you know it's racist?
Because someone told you?


@jj-adams said
Are you trying to claim the video is fake?
Oh...that's right, you won't watch it.
Also if you've never been to Amren how do you know it's racist?
Because someone told you?
Been to it and we both know it's a racist site. That's why you go to it.

I've seen people get punched before; that doesn't mean they've suffered a "physical injury" as defined by the NY Penal Law.


@no1marauder said
Been to it and we both know it's a racist site. That's why you go to it.

I've seen people get punched before; that doesn't mean they've suffered a "physical injury" as defined by the NY Penal Law.
There is nothing remotely racist about the site.
Unless you can give an example of such, stop claiming it.
WATCH THE VIDEO


@JJ-Adams
I guess this kind of thing is fine with you:

https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/white-teen-charged-allegedly-attempting-drown-black-teen-calling-racia-rcna103640


@sonhouse said
@JJ-Adams
I guess this kind of thing is fine with you:

https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/white-teen-charged-allegedly-attempting-drown-black-teen-calling-racia-rcna103640
I notice they aren't being released with no bail and there's a big public and media outcry over it.
Where's the outrage for the white teen stomped to death by 15 mau-mau's?


@no1marauder said
I won't go to a blatantly racist site like American Renaissance.

Are you disputing your own cited article's report that the cop suffered only minor injuries and was treated at the scene?

EDIT: Oh sorry the New York Post didn't mention that inconvenient fact.
You wont go becuse you do not want to see American Africans doing their thing, Marauder. You would have no comment, or your comment woujd have to be crap, would have to be disingenous.
OK to let them go. Yeah. Right. Oh, my video did not pop for some reason, but i know they were American Africans. Not many caucasions in videos like JJ has mentioned.


@no1marauder said
I won't go to a blatantly racist site like American Renaissance.

Are you disputing your own cited article's report that the cop suffered only minor injuries and was treated at the scene?

EDIT: Oh sorry the New York Post didn't mention that inconvenient fact.
If it had been you getting beat up like the cop in the video you wouldn't think it was so minor.


@AverageJoe1
African Americans. I bet you don't say it that way in private.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@sonhouse said
@AverageJoe1
African Americans. I bet you don't say it that way in private.
😂😂😂

you tender little thing

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.