Go back
NHL rules

NHL rules

Debates

b
Cheesy

Home

Joined
29 Apr 05
Moves
19877
Clock
07 Oct 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

now that you have seen the new rules in action do you think it was a good idea?
I personaly like it, make the games faster paced.

k

Joined
04 Nov 03
Moves
6803
Clock
07 Oct 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by blindcheesecake
now that you have seen the new rules in action do you think it was a good idea?
I personaly like it, make the games faster paced.
It's kind of like steroid pumped baseball compared to old time ball. Sure there's more scoring, but you give up so much.

f

Joined
11 May 05
Moves
6544
Clock
07 Oct 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by blindcheesecake
now that you have seen the new rules in action do you think it was a good idea?
I personaly like it, make the games faster paced.
My first impression was not a good one. with the blue line moved back and the two line pass rule hacked players are so spread out that checking does not even occur. Sure they score more but it takes away some of the effort and reward of a goal. I liked the dump chase slam play the puck infront of the net and hope the goalie or defender can make a good save. I am a big fan of the big hit but it is still too early to tell how the rule change went. I just glad hockey is back and I can watch something besides baseball. I am also trying to catch up on all the changes each team wnet through. Players are so shifted around and I have not seen it been played since a year ago. I am trying to catch up on the management aspect of it. But my first impression of the rules was not good but not too bad

U
All Bark, No Bite

Playing percussion

Joined
13 Jul 05
Moves
13279
Clock
07 Oct 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

The game was more interesting with less goals I thought. No final opinion yet, but thats my first impression.

DC
Flamenco Sketches

Spain, in spirit

Joined
09 Sep 04
Moves
59422
Clock
07 Oct 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by blindcheesecake
now that you have seen the new rules in action do you think it was a good idea?
I personaly like it, make the games faster paced.
It looks good to me, too. The worst thing that ever happened to the NHL (lockout notwithstanding) was the New Jersey Devils winning the cup in '95 with the 'Neutral Zone Trap'. It ushered in the most boring brand of hockey I could have imagined. Having grown up on Kurri, Gretzky and Messier flying around the rink in Edmonton, hockey should be about skilled players, to hell with the clutch and grab routine.

M
me, not you

CaNaDa

Joined
25 Nov 04
Moves
46658
Clock
07 Oct 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by friendlyneighbor14
My first impression was not a good one. with the blue line moved back and the two line pass rule hacked players are so spread out that checking does not even occur. Sure they score more but it takes away some of the effort and reward of a goal. I liked the dump chase slam play the puck infront of the net and hope the goalie or defender can mak ...[text shortened]... the management aspect of it. But my first impression of the rules was not good but not too bad
I think you will start seeing more big open ice hits.. as people will be looking for the long pass, and moving fast so when they collide it will be huge..
I like the icing rule about not able to change your lines.. that will stop all the icings..

U

Joined
07 Sep 05
Moves
444
Clock
08 Oct 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

I feel the new rules eliminate team strategy in the game and instead showcase talent. One of the reasons why I prefer hockey over other sports, is teamwork/strategy plays a bigger role then simply having the best talented/star players.

j

CA, USA

Joined
06 Dec 02
Moves
1182
Clock
09 Oct 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

50 yrs as a Red Wing fan tell me .. it's interesting, but it's just not NHL hockey IMO.
The handwriting was on the wall the day they made the "Gretzky rules."
You can throw out the record books right now .. none of those names will be their in 10-20 yrs.
Here's a thought ... maybe they could wear skirts instead of those huge shorts .. i'd be more suited to the way the game is played nowadays

U

Joined
07 Sep 05
Moves
444
Clock
09 Oct 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by jammer
50 yrs as a Red Wing fan tell me .. it's interesting, but it's just not NHL hockey IMO.
The handwriting was on the wall the day they made the "Gretzky rules."
You can throw out the record books right now .. none of those names will be their in 10-20 yrs.
Here's a thought ... maybe they could wear skirts instead of those huge shorts .. i'd be more suited to the way the game is played nowadays
Yeah, I watched the Leafs/Canadians game right now, what a joke of a game that was. Yeah, the flurries of goals being given out like free i-pods was nice and it's nice the little (the smaller you are, the harder you are to hit on this open ice) speedy team won (no, actually it wasn't) That wasn't hockey, more like a heartless pagent! I couldn't get excited over the game, the only thing the game had a lot of was wild out of flow goals, other then that the game lacked everything good in hockey, snoozefest. 😴😴😴

Whoever wins the cup this year, doesn't deserve it. This is going to kill hockey, it will be remembered as the year of the strike, followed by the year they took away earning the cup. Blows! 😴😴😴

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.