Go back
Quality, Quantity, and Naivete in Comparative Military Force Analysis

Quality, Quantity, and Naivete in Comparative Military Force Analysis

Debates

2 edits

3 edits
Vote Up
Vote Down

The post that was quoted here has been removed
This is generally true, however 2 things must be considered:

1. Under the N-square law: It does not apply to whole armies, where tactical deployment means not all troops will be engaged all the time. It only works where each unit (soldier, ship, etc.) can kill only one equivalent unit at a time. This is often the case since the N-square law doesn't take into consideration difficult terrain, inclement weather, disease, and differences in battlefield tactics. The N-square law is a classic case of a formula that can be helpful in designing a military force, but is only occasionally relevant in the gritty toils of war.

2. If you're comparing very large armies such as China, Russia, or the USA a war that threatens their very survival will undoubtedly trigger the use of nuclear weapons. This will make formulas and calculations of armies shooting at each other rather useless.

1 edit


Surely it’s the basis on which 50.000 T34’s managed to beat 1.200 Tiger tanks.

3 edits

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.