Debates
12 May 13
Originally posted by wolfgang59Despite the news stories, I don't think there ever was plans for this by any state political figures.
What happened to the pre-xmas story about some states (Texas?) wanting
to leave the USA and become independent. Was it a joke? Is there any
political will to do this?
Advantages/disadvantages of a devolved America?
Originally posted by wolfgang59Surprisingly a large number of States have resolutions of session each year. Not many of them even get to the stage of a vote.
What happened to the pre-xmas story about some states (Texas?) wanting
to leave the USA and become independent. Was it a joke? Is there any
political will to do this?
Advantages/disadvantages of a devolved America?
Originally posted by wolfgang59It would require a Federal Amendment. Otherwise, civil war.
But the mechanism already exists for states to leave?
Are commonwealths any different?
Commonwealths don't have a central entity that is dominant over the member countries like the USA does. Any nation in the Commonwealth could leave if it wanted to without being attacked by the Commonwealth unlike here.
Its more like the British Empire than the Commonwealth except that our leaders are elected representatives from all over instead of hereditary nobility.
Originally posted by AThousandYoungI meant commonwealths within the USA - are they constitutionally different
It would require a Federal Amendment. Otherwise, civil war.
Commonwealths don't have a central entity that is dominant over the member countries like the USA does. Any nation in the Commonwealth could leave if it wanted to without being attacked by the Commonwealth unlike here.
Its more like the British Empire than the Commonwealth except that our leaders are elected representatives from all over instead of hereditary nobility.
to states?
(eg Pennsylvania)