Go back
The Atlantic Tunnel

The Atlantic Tunnel

Debates

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by royalchicken
I can't be bothered to read the article, but how do they plan to move people through a tunnel at well over 3 000 mph?
The idea is to pump out all the air in the tunnel and fire a mag-lev train down it. 18 minutes of acceleration to a 5000 mph cruise, then 18 minutes of deceleration at the end.
I think it's a pipe dream too, mainly because of the cost, plus I can't see any need to get across the Atlantic that fast for most people. The same thing could be done less expensively and with greater flexibility by something like the scramjet.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by royalchicken
I can't be bothered to read the article, but how do they plan to move people through a tunnel at well over 3 000 mph?
THAT is a very good question.

1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Varg
Anything so groan-worthy is worth a rec in my book 🙂
I was surprise the thread went this far without anyone saying it! Come on folks!

P-

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by KneverKnight
The idea is to pump out all the air in the tunnel and fire a mag-lev train down it. 18 minutes of acceleration to a 5000 mph cruise, then 18 minutes of deceleration at the end.
I think it's a pipe dream too, mainly because of the cost, plus I can't see any need to get across the Atlantic that fast for most people. The same thing could be done less expensively and with greater flexibility by something like the scramjet.
I don't have the right plugins to view it, so I can't find out how deep this tunnel is, but it would require enormous strength to pull a vacuum and not have it collapse under the water pressure at the deepest parts of the bottom of the Atlantic. Also, how would it handle the necessary 3-dimensional bends in the pipe at that speed?

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by royalchicken
I don't have the right plugins to view it, so I can't find out how deep this tunnel is, but it would require enormous strength to pull a vacuum and not have it collapse under the water pressure at the deepest parts of the bottom of the Atlantic. Also, how would it handle the necessary 3-dimensional bends in the pipe at that speed?
I don't know exactly how it would take a curve, the idea is to have the tunnel as straight as possible.
The tunnel won't hug the ocean bottom, the pressure is too great. It will be tethered some distance beneath the surface to hundreds of anchors.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by KneverKnight
I don't know exactly how it would take a curve, the idea is to have the tunnel as straight as possible.
The tunnel won't hug the ocean bottom, the pressure is too great. It will be tethered some distance beneath the surface to hundreds of anchors.
While they're spending money, why not just buy rights to the Atlantic, build the thing on the surface, and give shipping companies a reason to go find the Northwest Passage?

Vote Up
Vote Down

No train out of London gets anywhere in 54 minutes, trust me. This tunnel may cost 3 squillion pounds to build but it will still suffer from signalling problems and defective radios.

Rich.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Thumbs down to the Atlantic Tunnel.
Time for a new thread.

Vote Up
Vote Down

So what are they going to call this thing? The Atunnel? Atlunnel?