Go back
the Danish/USA Greenland treaty

the Danish/USA Greenland treaty

Debates

1 edit

the USA can militarize Greenland any time it wants.

https://avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/den001.asp

treaty rights established in 1951.


@the-grifter

From what I read in the Swedish press, it is not likely to happen. Let's hope the negotiations will result in something good for all parties and that America stays away from what is not theirs. Military actions are not the best solution even if your president seems to believe that.


@Torunn
treaty rights are a product of diplomacy.

Denmark can break the treaty if they choose to do so.

there would be consequences for that of course.


@the-grifter said
@Torunn
treaty rights are a product of diplomacy.

Denmark can break the treaty if they choose to do so.

there would be consequences for that of course.
Let's hope common sense will rule this matter.


@Torunn said
Let's hope common sense will rule this matter.
Thats wishful thinking. I was reading up on this issue and it appears Trump is hellbent on getting some kind of control of Greenland. Denmark and NATO countries on the whole will be well advised to put on their negotiating caps so that some good can come of it instead of confrontation. Trump will win if there is confrontation. USA and Europe need to be allies regardless of what happens. Falling out over Greenland is going to be loss for Europe, not USA.

1 edit

@Rajk999 said
Thats wishful thinking. I was reading up on this issue and it appears Trump is hellbent on getting some kind of control of Greenland. Denmark and NATO countries on the whole will be well advised to put on their negotiating caps so that some good can come of it instead of confrontation. Trump will win if there is confrontation. USA and Europe need to be allies regardless of what happens. Falling out over Greenland is going to be loss for Europe, not USA.
Trump wants many things in spite of what many Americans feel. He acts for himself, it's all about him.


@Torunn
what will happen when the Danish pm meets with the president this week will be a mutual understanding that nato will drift west to Greenland and after american development of the mineral rights the citizens of denmark and Greenland will get rich on their share of the money to be paid. each place will have it's integrity but all will understand that it will be American forces that have the military umbrella of Greenland and thus the chinese and Russian ships that currently patrol north of Greenland will only have polar bears to take pictures of before they sail home.

1 edit

@the-grifter said
@Torunn
what will happen when the Danish pm meets with the president this week will be a mutual understanding that nato will drift west to Greenland and after american development of the mineral rights the citizens of denmark and Greenland will get rich on their share of the money to be paid. each place will have it's integrity but all will understand that it will be A ...[text shortened]... ntly patrol north of Greenland will only have polar bears to take pictures of before they sail home.
As long as all parties agree, which doesn't seem to be the case right now.


@Torunn said
Trump wants many things in spite of what many Americans feel. He acts for himself, it's all about him.
Yeah, and that little fact, is something the negotiators will do well ignore. Its irrelevant. I hope they are able to tango with Trump.


@Torunn
the president is a businessman. you negotiate from a high position until you find the point where the other side is finally willing to tell you what they really want from the deal and then you close the deal so that everyone takes away from the table something of value.

remember, trump spent his life as a builder in the new York/new Jersey area. construction, trash, hotel unions, etc. what do you think he was dealing with....the Mafia as well as honest people.

the president knows how to close a deal even when their are seemingly obstacles that others would walk away from.


@Rajk999 said
Yeah, and that little fact, is something the negotiators will do well ignore. Its irrelevant. I hope they are able to tango with Trump.
Are the Americans irrelevant to Trump?


@Torunn said
Are the Americans irrelevant to Trump?
Im not an authority on that, but I can say that Trump intends to do what he thinks is in the best interest of the USA. The Greenland issue is about US security re Russia and China being able to access shipping routes. I dont know the details.

More than half of the US population is oblivious about world affairs, so what they want may not be relevant.


@the-grifter said
@Torunn
the president is a businessman. you negotiate from a high position until you find the point where the other side is finally willing to tell you what they really want from the deal and then you close the deal so that everyone takes away from the table something of value.

remember, trump spent his life as a builder in the new York/new Jersey area. construction ...[text shortened]... knows how to close a deal even when their are seemingly obstacles that others would walk away from.
As I said, all parties should agree to a good deal which I don't think they will yet. Don't overrate Trump and underestimate other actors, they are smart people too, and they have integrity and responsibilities.


@Rajk999 said
Im not an authority on that, but I can say that Trump intends to do what he thinks is in the best interest of the USA. The Greenland issue is about US security re Russia and China being able to access shipping routes. I dont know the details.

More than half of the US population is oblivious about world affairs, so what they want may not be relevant.
And there you have a dictator ignoring the American population.


@Torunn said
And there you have a dictator ignoring the American population.
Yes, you are right, but again, that has nothing to do with the negotiation between Denmark and Trump. I hope they are smart enough to understand Trump. Badmouthing Trump is going to be a mistake.

I know you enjoy doing that but in the actual discussion among the leaders, its useless.