This lady was mad!

This lady was mad!

Debates

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.

aw
Baby Gauss

Ceres

Joined
14 Oct 06
Moves
18375
19 Apr 10

And by mad I mean pi$$ed mad. Why didn't they film her instead?



http://www.chomsky.info/articles/1986----.htm

When the world's two great propaganda systems agree on some doctrine, it requires some intellectual effort to escape its shackles. One such doctrine is that the society created by Lenin and Trotsky and molded further by Stalin and his successors has some relation to socialism in some meaningful or historically accurate sense of this concept. In fact, if there is a relation, it is the relation of contradiction.

P
Upward Spiral

Halfway

Joined
02 Aug 04
Moves
8702
19 Apr 10

Why, adam, you haven't caught on that the idealized socialism you have in mind only exists as a propaganda weapon?

aw
Baby Gauss

Ceres

Joined
14 Oct 06
Moves
18375
19 Apr 10

Originally posted by Palynka
Why, adam, you haven't caught on that the idealized socialism you have in mind only exists as a propaganda weapon?
I think you're missing the point. But if you'd expand a little bit more I'll try to answer.

P
Upward Spiral

Halfway

Joined
02 Aug 04
Moves
8702
19 Apr 10
1 edit

Originally posted by adam warlock
I think you're missing the point. But if you'd expand a little bit more I'll try to answer.
Meh. Since you're doing a zeeblebot and just pasting a link with a selected quote I'll probably pass.

Edit - I haven't watched the video, but I'm probably more interested in Chomsky's opinions.

silicon valley

Joined
27 Oct 04
Moves
101289
19 Apr 10

list of successful socialist entities, please.

T

Joined
13 Mar 07
Moves
48661
19 Apr 10
1 edit

Originally posted by zeeblebot
list of successful socialist entities, please.
Well, according to the wild right wingers on this site, most of Europe qualifies as "socialist". And for all its problems, it's reasonably successful by international standards.

F

Unknown Territories

Joined
05 Dec 05
Moves
20408
19 Apr 10

Originally posted by Teinosuke
Well, according to the wild right wingers on this site, most of Europe qualifies as "socialist". And for all its problems, it's reasonably successful by international standards.
Kindergärtners who know their place. Nothing more, nothing less.

K

Germany

Joined
27 Oct 08
Moves
3118
19 Apr 10

Originally posted by Teinosuke
Well, according to the wild right wingers on this site, most of Europe qualifies as "socialist". And for all its problems, it's reasonably successful by international standards.
It's a funny little dichotomy, isn't it? Obama is "socialist" - even though his policies so far place him on par with or to the right of right-wing parties in most of the industrialized world - so by that definition, almost every democratic nation in the world is "socialist". Yet when they are asking for socialism's successes, they claim there are none despite the high standard of living in many - apparently socialist - industrialized nations.

aw
Baby Gauss

Ceres

Joined
14 Oct 06
Moves
18375
19 Apr 10

Originally posted by Palynka
Meh. Since you're doing a zeeblebot and just pasting a link with a selected quote I'll probably pass.

Edit - I haven't watched the video, but I'm probably more interested in Chomsky's opinions.
In that case why address me in the first place? 😕

silicon valley

Joined
27 Oct 04
Moves
101289
19 Apr 10

Originally posted by Teinosuke
Well, according to the wild right wingers on this site, most of Europe qualifies as "socialist". And for all its problems, it's reasonably successful by international standards.
how can they be socialist if they're capitalist?

F

Joined
28 Oct 05
Moves
34587
20 Apr 10

Originally posted by zeeblebot
how can they be socialist if they're capitalist?
Ah yes, another old chesnut from the made-in-the-U.S. Three Day Master's Degree in Political Science.

silicon valley

Joined
27 Oct 04
Moves
101289
20 Apr 10

are there a bunch of eur-o-pee-ins running around chanting "we're the SOCIALIST capitalists!"?

K

Germany

Joined
27 Oct 08
Moves
3118
20 Apr 10

Originally posted by zeeblebot
are there a bunch of eur-o-pee-ins running around chanting "we're the SOCIALIST capitalists!"?
Not literally, but for example the Dutch Socialist Party does not want to abolish capitalism.

silicon valley

Joined
27 Oct 04
Moves
101289
20 Apr 10

Originally posted by KazetNagorra
Not literally, but for example the Dutch Socialist Party does not want to abolish capitalism.
well, then. wouldn't that disqualify them from the list?

Quiz Master

RHP Arms

Joined
09 Jun 07
Moves
48793
20 Apr 10

Originally posted by zeeblebot
well, then. wouldn't that disqualify them from the list?
Are you going to tell them?
Or sue them for false advertising?

I think most people understand "Socialism" as a democracy with
some sort of welfare state
a policy of redistribution of wealth through taxation
legislation on markets (particularly monopolies)
and perhaps above all a fair society

a long way from Marx!!