@no1marauder saidYour link is to a Turkey media organization controlled by the govt.
Here's the assessment of various Jewish organizations of Trump's support of Netanyahu's vision: https://www.aa.com.tr/en/americas/jewish-groups-in-us-blast-trumps-mideast-peace-plan/1717414
2 edits
@Mott-The-Hoople saidAre you denying the comments in the article were made by leaders of various Jewish organizations?
Your link is to a Turkey media organization controlled by the govt.
Here's another: https://www.jta.org/2020/01/28/united-states/heres-how-jewish-groups-are-reacting-to-the-trump-peace-plan
Are these guys "supporters of any crime against Jews and Israelis" too?
@no1marauder saidPer your latest link…
Are you denying the comments in the article were made by leaders of various Jewish organizations?
Here's another: https://www.jta.org/2020/01/28/united-states/heres-how-jewish-groups-are-reacting-to-the-trump-peace-plan
Are these guys "supporters of any crime against Jews and Israelis" too?
(JTA) — Reactions to President Donald Trump’s Israeli-Palestinian peace plan unveiled Tuesday took a predictable path, with Jewish groups on the right praising the much-anticipated proposal and those on the left criticizing it.
The proposal, which Trump presented at a news conference with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, would give Israel the Jordan Valley and parts of the West Bank while freezing for four years the areas that the U.S. proposes as part of a future Palestinian state. A Palestinian state would be made up of Gaza and the majority of the West Bank, which would be connected via high-speed rail, and have East Jerusalem as its capital.
Israel would also get “overriding security responsibility and control over entire territory from the Jordan River to the Mediterranean Sea,” U.S. Ambassador to Israel David Friedman said in a follow-up call with reporters. The White House released a 180-page document that elaborated on the details of the plan.
Here’s what Jewish groups have to say about the proposal (JTA will add add reactions as they come in).
The Republican Jewish Coalition endorsed the plan. Executive Director Matt Brooks said “[t]he President and his team have put together a bold and nuanced proposal that is deeply rooted in America’s core values of liberty, opportunity, and hope for the future.”
The American Israel Public Affairs Committee said it “appreciate[s] the efforts of President Trump and his administration to work in consultation with the leaders of the two major Israeli political parties to set forth ideas to resolve the conflict in a way that recognizes our ally’s critical security needs.” AIPAC urged the “Palestinians to rejoin Israelis at the negotiating table.”
ADVERTISEMENT
The American Jewish Committee said on Twitter that it “welcomes President Trump’s serious effort to resolve the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, assuring Israel’s security & Jerusalem’s uncontested status, while creating a path to Palestinian statehood.”
StandWithUs CEO Roz Rothstein said the group “hope[s] this will be a step towards a better future for both peoples” and that “it is ultimately up to Israeli and Palestinian leaders to resolve their conflict through direct negotiations.”
@Mott-The-Hoople saidNice cherry picking; the point is people can disagree with Netanyahu's policies and Trump's support for Crimes Against Humanity without being "anti-Jewish".
Per your latest link…
(JTA) — Reactions to President Donald Trump’s Israeli-Palestinian peace plan unveiled Tuesday took a predictable path, with Jewish groups on the right praising the much-anticipated proposal and those on the left criticizing it.
The proposal, which Trump presented at a news conference with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, would g ...[text shortened]... mately up to Israeli and Palestinian leaders to resolve their conflict through direct negotiations.”
@wildgrass saidit's a direct threat to Palestinians.
I think the language isn't a direct threat to Palestinians. He suggests it in the same way he suggests that we nuke hurricanes or inject bleach. A stream of consciousness without a filter.
@no1marauder saidcherry picking is exactly what you were doing with your first link
Nice cherry picking; the point is people can disagree with Netanyahu's policies and Trump's support for Crimes Against Humanity without being "anti-Jewish".
@Mott-The-Hoople saidNope, I was proving my point.
cherry picking is exactly what you were doing with your first link
You decided to cut and paste half an article ignoring the rest which supported what I said. That's " cherry picking".
@no1marauder saidyour first link was to a site that only presented ONE SIDE, YOU posted another link that included BOTH sides. I selected only one side...just proving my point of what you had done with your first link.
Nope, I was proving my point.
You decided to cut and paste half an article ignoring the rest which supported what I said. That's " cherry picking".
1 edit
@no1marauder saidOh come on, this is so bloody obvious. The Trump family intends to develop Gaza's "prime waterfront property" and plant 5-star hotels and 18-hole golf courses there.
Specifically "ethnic cleansing":
"Donald Trump is facing backlash after he suggested Saturday "we just clean out" the Gaza Strip, with critics accusing the president of supporting ethnic cleansing.
Speaking on Air Force One, Trump told reporters that Egypt and Jordan should accept the Palestinian refugees who would be displaced by the plan.
"[b]You're talking abo ...[text shortened]... .britannica.com/topic/ethnic-cleansing
Where's a tribunal with a gallows handy when you need one?
https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2024/mar/19/jared-kushner-gaza-waterfront-property-israel-negev
The Palestinians will be welcome to come back, once the place is 'cleaned up' and developed, and they could seek jobs as, you know, janitors and waitresses and gardeners in the hotels and on the links.
This is a total win-win.
For both Donald and Jared....
@moonbus saidGreat idea, but Hamas and Hezbollah are not likely to sit and watch that happen. They have already promised another Oct7th style attack. With the hundreds of terrorists released from Israeli prisoners and new recruits [15,000 I believe], they will do another rape and kill Jews effort. It aint over.
Oh come on, this is so bloody obvious. The Trump family intends to develop Gaza's "prime waterfront property" and plant 5-star hotels and 18-hole golf courses there.
https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2024/mar/19/jared-kushner-gaza-waterfront-property-israel-negev
The Palestinians will be welcome to come back, once the place is 'cleaned up' and developed, and they cou ...[text shortened]... ers in the hotels and on the links.
This is a total win-win.
For both Donald and Jared....
@Rajk999 saidTrump doesn't give a rat's a$$ about that. It's not 'America first' with him, it's 'business first.' If he thinks he can make a profit out of war, he'll wage war; if he thinks he can make a profit out of peace, he'll make peace.
Great idea, but Hamas and Hezbollah are not likely to sit and watch that happen. They have already promised another Oct7th style attack. With the hundreds of terrorists released from Israeli prisoners and new recruits [15,000 I believe], they will do another rape and kill Jews effort. It aint over.
@Rajk999 saidGlad to see you now recognize that Netanyahu's war in Gaza has been an abject failure not achieving the objectives he used to justify it.
Great idea, but Hamas and Hezbollah are not likely to sit and watch that happen. They have already promised another Oct7th style attack. With the hundreds of terrorists released from Israeli prisoners and new recruits [15,000 I believe], they will do another rape and kill Jews effort. It aint over.
Hamas isn't destroyed.
Some of the hostages are dead, others are being released at a snail's pace and only with many more Palestinian prisoners being freed.
I hate to say I told you so, but you know ........
@no1marauder saidGrasping at straws? The war destroyed Hamas, most of Hezbollah and some of Iran's nuclear capability, plus it hopefully taught Palestinians a lesson. But they are stupid people and will support another Oct 7th attack.
Glad to see you now recognize that Netanyahu's war in Gaza has been an abject failure not achieving the objectives he used to justify it.
Hamas isn't destroyed.
Some of the hostages are dead, others are being released at a snail's pace and only with many more Palestinian prisoners being freed.
I hate to say I told you so, but you know ........
The hostage exchange is the mistake. Hamas is going to rebuild. The Jews will just have another war on their hands soon, and hopefully this time will use the proper weapons to finish them completely.
@moonbus saidWell peace now can make money for developers with deep pockets... hopefully that will happen and Palestinians can get real jobs instead of begging the world for money and working for Hamas.
Trump doesn't give a rat's a$$ about that. It's not 'America first' with him, it's 'business first.' If he thinks he can make a profit out of war, he'll wage war; if he thinks he can make a profit out of peace, he'll make peace.