Go back
A question on grammar

A question on grammar

General

1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by shavixmir
"I was sat at the pub drinking a beer."
"I was sitting at the pub drinking a beer."

[b]Why
is one of the two correct and why is the other wrong?

Bowmann?[/b]
They're both wrong.

I was in the pub, drinking beer.

Or

I sat in the pub, having a beer.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Nordlys
I was sotten?
At my office we have recently been discussing the habit in American English to take a word and shove on some endings to convey the required meaning with no regard to whether the word is a legitimate one or not.

A word thus perverted we refer to as an "Americanisationism",

I see you might be be able to help us expand our dictionary. Or, more correctly, expanderizeate our dictionary!

However, back to the thread. I believe the correct expression would be "I satinatedizmed in the bar"

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Wheely
"I satinatedizmed in the bar"
It happens, especially after a few pints.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by shavixmir
"I was sat at the pub drinking a beer."
"I was sitting at the pub drinking a beer."

[b]Why
is one of the two correct and why is the other wrong?

I was using the first sentence on my blog (twice) and twice I've been brought up on it.
I don't understand what's wrong with the first sentence and I would be very grateful if someone would explain it to me.

Bowmann?[/b]
The problem with the first sentence is that it contains a negligible grammar mistake that attracts moronic, lonely, desperate grammar Nazi's that have nothing else better to do than laze about online making pedantic comments while they're waiting for their cheap porn to download.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by shavixmir
"I was sat at the pub drinking a beer."
"I was sitting at the pub drinking a beer."

[b]Why
is one of the two correct and why is the other wrong?

I was using the first sentence on my blog (twice) and twice I've been brought up on it.
I don't understand what's wrong with the first sentence and I would be very grateful if someone would explain it to me.

Bowmann?[/b]
They are both incorrect.

It should be: "I sat at the pub while drinking a beer" or "I was sitting at the pub while drinking a beer."

This way one is not confused that you are so damn drunk that the one might think the pub is doing the drinking.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Wheely
satinatedizmed
That's an interestinating wordity!

Vote Up
Vote Down

Regardless of whether one manner of expressing oneself is correct over another you can rest assured that Shav was pissed, phoning up everyone he knows and telling them that he loves them!

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by kirksey957
They are both incorrect.

It should be: "I sat at the pub while drinking a beer" or "I was sitting at the pub while drinking a beer."

This way one is not confused that you are so damn drunk that the one might think the pub is doing the drinking.
Plonker.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Nordlys
That's an interestinating wordity!
You're a natural!!

Or possibly, you naturalizeatedlyizmed!

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by shavixmir
"I was sat at the pub drinking a beer."
"I was sitting at the pub drinking a beer."

[b]Why
is one of the two correct and why is the other wrong?

I was using the first sentence on my blog (twice) and twice I've been brought up on it.
I don't understand what's wrong with the first sentence and I would be very grateful if someone would explain it to me.

Bowmann?[/b]
*I was sat* might be correct if you're a toddler and your parents plopped you into the chair.

Vote Up
Vote Down

There are three things to think about.
One: is it grammatically correct?
Two: does it sound nice/correct/pleasing...?
Three: does it convey the meaning you intended?
Whether or not 'I was sat' is grammatically correct or not, it sounds terrible.
Ps: which of those three is least important? (Rhetorical)

"Rules are there to make you think before you break them"

1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Bowmann
They're both wrong.

I was in the pub, drinking beer.

Or

I sat in the pub, having a beer.
Thank you.

Not that everyone else's analysis is wrong, but I have a feeling you'll be right on this matter!

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by shavixmir
Thank you.

Not that everyone else's analysis is wrong, but I have a feeling you'll be right on this matter!
ahem

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by googlefudge
There are three things to think about.
One: is it grammatically correct?
Two: does it sound nice/correct/pleasing...?
Three: does it convey the meaning you intended?
Whether or not 'I was sat' is grammatically correct or not, it sounds terrible.
Ps: which of those three is least important? (Rhetorical)
It depends. If the intended meaning is completely boring, the third is least important. (I love to reply to rhetorical questions.)

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Nordlys
It depends. If the intended meaning is completely boring, the third is least important. (I love to reply to rhetorical questions.)
I want it published.