Go back
A serious question for vegans.

A serious question for vegans.

General

Nemesio
Ursulakantor

Pittsburgh, PA

Joined
05 Mar 02
Moves
34824
Clock
24 Oct 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

I can fathom the reasons and justifications (nutritional, ethical, and environmental) for not eating milk (and related products, such as ice cream or cheese).

What about the idea of making cheese or ice cream from human breast milk? Certainly there are no ethical or environmental conflicts. As for nutritional, I haven't a clue.

Mind you, I don't have the slightest clue what breast milk tastes like; goat milk tastes different from cow milk, so (for all I know) it could be really grim tasting. The reason I ask is because I'm trying to goad my wife (who is lactating) into producing a little extra to try this experiment.

Has anyone tried this?

Nemesio

w
Jo

Moving on...

Joined
18 Nov 03
Moves
44943
Clock
24 Oct 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

i think it is quite sweet and watery....breast milk changes so it would depend on when you wanted to 'try' your experiment...In the 1st stages the milk is thick and creamy...this is called 'colustram'......so how do you want yours??? full fat or skimmed??

pradtf

VeggieChess

Joined
03 Jun 02
Moves
7483
Clock
24 Oct 04
5 edits
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by nemesio
I can fathom the reasons and justifications (nutritional, ethical, and environmental) for not eating milk (and related products, such as ice cream or cheese).

What about the idea of making cheese or ice cream from human breast milk? Cer ...[text shortened]... extra to try this experiment.

Has anyone tried this?

Nemesio
seriously, the milk really is not for the already weaned who tend to lose the ability to breakdown certain components like lactose, which may be why something like 70% of the adult population is actually lactose intolerant:

Lactose intolerance, the inability to digest the sugar found in milk, is widespread and affects up to 70% of the world's adult population ... Lactose intolerance is found in as many as 75% of African Americans, Jewish Americans, Mexican Americans, and Native Americans, and in 90% of Asian Americans. Descendants of Northern Europeans and some Mediterranean peoples usually do not develop the condition.
http://www.healthatoz.com/healthatoz/Atoz/ency/carbohydrate_intolerance.jsp

(human milk btw has nearly twice the lactose concentration as bovine milk:
http://classes.aces.uiuc.edu/AnSci308/HumanLact.html)

btw, goat's milk is supposed to be closest to human milk (i've heard back in the 70s), but i can't recall why off hand.

the rights issue on this is most interesting and profound though.

in friendship,
prad

AThousandYoung
1st Dan TKD Kukkiwon

tinyurl.com/2te6yzdu

Joined
23 Aug 04
Moves
26758
Clock
24 Oct 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

A nutritional, or disease related, danger would be that human milk is more likely to harbor human disease microorganisms than cow milk is. Also, you're going to have to obtain it yourself, so the chance you might screw something up will be higher than if a professional company or diaryperson were to gather and process the milk.

Siskin

over your head

Joined
12 Jul 04
Moves
23004
Clock
24 Oct 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by wucky3
full fat or skimmed??
full fat gold top for me!

e

Joined
03 Dec 03
Moves
25735
Clock
25 Oct 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by nemesio
I can fathom the reasons and justifications (nutritional, ethical, and environmental) for not eating milk (and related products, such as ice cream or cheese).

What about the idea of making cheese or ice cream from human breast milk? Certainly there are no ethical or environmental conflicts. As for nutritional, I haven't a clue.

Mind you, I don't ha ...[text shortened]... ting) into producing a little extra to try this experiment.

Has anyone tried this?

Nemesio
Are you going to make cheese from her breast milk?
I believ you would need quite a bity of it?
Are you planning on milking her by hand or using the suction pump thingy?
😀

e

Joined
03 Dec 03
Moves
25735
Clock
25 Oct 04
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by nemesio
I can fathom the reasons and justifications (nutritional, ethical, and environmental) for not eating milk (and related products, such as ice cream or cheese).

What about the idea of making cheese or ice cream from human breast milk? Cer ...[text shortened]... extra to try this experiment.

Has anyone tried this?

Nemesio
Are you going to make cheese from her breast milk?
I believ you would need quite a bity of it?
Are you planning on milking her by hand or using the suction pump thingy?
😀
Goat milk tastes almost exactly like cow's milk. Sheep's milk tastes like melted ice cream
vanilla

t

Joined
19 Aug 02
Moves
103329
Clock
25 Oct 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

That is a lot of breast milk required for a tiny bit of cheese. Just how much milk do you think you can get from your wife ??

g
Wayward Soul

Your Blackened Sky

Joined
12 Mar 02
Moves
15128
Clock
25 Oct 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

i work in a hotel restaurant, and we had a wedding party in. now, some people hadn't ordered vegitarian meals, or had but it hadn't got through, or something...but anyway-we served them the meat dish. they then asked for the vegitariona one instead as they were vegies. we said "sure!" and gave them the veggie one. then chucked the meat one in the bin...

what's the point?!? the thing still dies-tis either you eat it, or it dies for no reason!

okay-so that's not always the case, but the amount of meat that is thrown out cause of veggies is actually quite surprising...😛

V
Thinking...

Odersfelt

Joined
20 Jan 03
Moves
14580
Clock
25 Oct 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by genius
what's the point?!? the thing still dies-tis either you eat it, or it dies for no reason!
I'm a vegetarian, and I wouldn't eat meat that was put in front of me beacuse it had already died.
What fault is it of mine that somebody killed, butchered and cooked an animal?

AThousandYoung
1st Dan TKD Kukkiwon

tinyurl.com/2te6yzdu

Joined
23 Aug 04
Moves
26758
Clock
25 Oct 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

If the demand for meat is less, then less meat will be produced in the future. If hotels keep tossing out meat, they will stop buying so much meat, or will be more careful to make sure people really want meat instead of assuming they do if they don't ask for vegetarian.

Also some people don't eat meat for other reasons.

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.