Go back
Area v Volume

Area v Volume

General

Vote Up
Vote Down

Does anyone know which shape has the most surface area in relationship to its volume (liquids) or is it a constant?


Originally posted by Campaigner
Does anyone know which shape has the most surface area in relationship to its volume (liquids) or is it a constant?
The RHP Science Forum "Scientific discussion and debate." would seem to be the place to post your question.



Originally posted by Campaigner
Does anyone know which shape has the most surface area in relationship to its volume (liquids) or is it a constant?
Polyhedron you mean? Hard one to answer. I'm not sure if you can quantify it as you can keep making them with a larger and larger surface area in comparison to volume. If you are talking about regular polyhedrons, then maybe there is some kind of formula to define this. If you are talking about irregular shapes then I think the possibilities are endless. Look at the small intestine or lung lining for example.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Campaigner
Does anyone know which shape has the most surface area in relationship to its volume (liquids) or is it a constant?
A sphere.

This is why liquids in weightlessness form a sphere.

Oh, wait, you said MOST surface area.

Sorry, the sphere has the LEAST surface area in relation to its volume.

If I were to hazard a guess, I'd say a tetrahedron. It's possible the answer needs more vertices, though.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Sicilian Sausage
Polyhedron you mean? Hard one to answer. I'm not sure if you can quantify it as you can keep making them with a larger and larger surface area in comparison to volume. If you are talking about regular polyhedrons, then maybe there is some kind of formula to define this. If you are talking about irregular shapes then I think the possibilities are endless. Look at the small intestine or lung lining for example.
Ooooooh, brilliant, I didn't even think of irregular surfaces.

2 edits
Vote Up
Vote Down

Yes a Sphere definitely has the lowest ratio and I would guess a tetrahedron would have the most as well. If n = the number of faces then as n tends to infinity then our shape would become a sphere. If you work back the other way it implies that the shape with the smallest number of possible faces would have the largest ratio i.e a tetrahedron.
Poink.
Or you could Google it 😀

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Campaigner
Does anyone know which shape has the most surface area in relationship to its volume (liquids) or is it a constant?
The answer would be a three dimensional object consisting of a surface of any shape, separated by distance d from a surface of any shape, as d approaches zero.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Point singularity, of course!

-m.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by JS357
The answer would be a three dimensional object consisting of a surface of any shape, separated by distance d from a surface of any shape, as d approaches zero.
Ah. I thought the OP was questioning the surface area to mass ratio of different shapes as a comparison. i.e. with a set volume for example. If you introduce size then yes, the smaller any object is, so increases said ratio, as n, d, v or whatever you want tends to 0.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Campaigner
Does anyone know which shape has the most surface area in relationship to its volume (liquids) or is it a constant?
Yes.
Quite a few people.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Google "Menger Sponge" if you want to join them.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Thanks for these answers - yes I should have mentioned it is a set volume (water in this case) - if a sphere is both the most and the least doesn't that make it a constant?

Vote Up
Vote Down

Brilliant! - more or less just what I was after.