Go back
Being a man...

Being a man...

General


@torunn said
What is it like being a man?
it's reconciling the requirements of evolution with the growth of understanding and never quite getting it right while pretending to have gotten it right the first time


when I was growing up I was taught that a man never showed fear or cried
got a job and took care of his family
things have changed


@very-rusty said
I believe that a man should be there for his children and wife and always show them love and support. "A man's got to do what man's got to do", is an expression that has been around for years. Said to mean that you will do whatever you have to do, even if it is difficult or dangerous. Your family comes before yourself.

-VR
The same as with women. We do what we must and hopefully it pleases us doing so. Nowadays, in our culture, men and women often share financial responsibilities for the good of the family and themselves of course.


@torunn said
There seem to be certain expectations of men that I don't quite understand. If there is a conflict between a man and a woman it should be between individuals - not their roles.
I don't think anybody reaches a point of knowing absolutely which expectations come from within and which come from outside. I don't think they know whether the ones coming from within were archetypal with an inevitable starting point that could only be shaped or whether they were introduced at some point in their journey.

An interesting question is how much are women involved in the creation and management of the expectations?


@torunn said
What is it like being a man? "Be a man", we hear as to encourage men to be a certain way. "A man's got to do what a man's got to do." As a woman, I can't help wondering: what is it like being a man? What do men feel is expected of them other than just being human?
Being tough when the situation calls for it, stepping up to tackle hardships or frightening situations, etc. Nothing you probably haven't heard before.

I've noticed: if a couple lives in a dirty house, people tend to blame the woman. If a couple can't pay their bills, people tend to blame the man. It doesn't matter if both are making the same amount of money or not. This is for obvious reasons.

In short, men are supposed to be as close to being Batman as possible.


@relentless-red said
I don't think anybody reaches a point of knowing absolutely which expectations come from within and which come from outside. I don't think they know whether the ones coming from within were archetypal with an inevitable starting point that could only be shaped or whether they were introduced at some point in their journey.

An interesting question is how much are women involved in the creation and management of the expectations?
A good question. Personally I would expect a man to be loyal above all - nothing particularly manly about that. We would share our money and responsibilities between us. He would prioritize his family. Nothing very manly about that.


@torunn said
I mean capitalizing the words.
I apologize to FMF, I misread his post. No harm meant but it caused a misunderstanding. He clearly stated what being a man meant to him and his family and I didn't read it right. Sorry.



@torunn said
A good question. Personally I would expect a man to be loyal above all - nothing particularly manly about that. We would share our money and responsibilities between us. He would prioritize his family. Nothing very manly about that.
Does that shape men not to be like that if women say that those are not very manly qualities? Perhaps the majority of men most want to appear manly in the eyes of women?


@relentless-red said
Does that shape men not to be like that if women say that those are not very manly qualities? Perhaps the majority of men most want to appear manly in the eyes of women?
Maybe. Maybe women don't need men to be very manly, just individuals with strong integrity.


@torunn said
Maybe. Maybe women don't need men to be very manly, just individuals with strong integrity.
I believe manly means having courage and strength. Correct me if I am wrong but would a woman not want a man to have both of these qualities? Integrity of course would be up there on the list for sure!

-VR

1 edit


@torunn said
Maybe. Maybe women don't need men to be very manly, just individuals with strong integrity.
Maybe you can have it both ways by developing a culture in which integrity is seen as a manly quality. Perhaps it is about the culture that men and women create.


@relentless-red said
Maybe you can have it both ways by developing a culture in which integrity is seen as a manly quality. Perhaps it is about the culture that men and women create.
Maybe we are on our way - very slowly.