Go back
Being a man...

Being a man...

General


@torunn said
Wouldn't being together, man and woman, be sufficient?
Not for someone asking the question in the OP.


@torunn said
Maybe. Maybe women don't need men to be very manly, just individuals with strong integrity.
And wallets. Mainly wallets.


-Removed-
I would hope that he doesn't feel the pressure to fit into a role of strength and ambitions. I would hope that he feels relaxed enough to have an open mind about himself.


@torunn said
Wouldn't being together, man and woman, be sufficient?
If that were the case, torunn, no man would go to war. Good or bad?

I think two genders were created for a reason. Men explore and hunt while women seem to be more attune to
people's needs in an emotional sense. Think children but it goes well beyond that. Nuturing.


@shallow-blue said
And wallets. Mainly wallets.
Men's wallets are not an issue we often speak of in this country, as I know it - we talk about money and economy regardless of who provides it. You may know that Sweden is a country where a lot of the population live single.


@earl-of-trumps said
If that were the case, torunn, no man would go to war. Good or bad?

I think two genders were created for a reason. Men explore and hunt while women seem to be more attune to
people's needs in an emotional sense. Think children but it goes well beyond that. Nuturing.
True, we are different and we have to learn to live with that. Our societies change and we have different roles now.


@torunn said
True, we are different and we have to learn to live with that. Our societies change and we have different roles now.
This thread could go on and on, but I think it is difficult to talk about the role of man without including
the role of woman, as the way I see it, the two must work together to successfully grow a village.
It's also self evident that men and women have different abilities and the two as a team have all the skills
working for the two (or more) of them.

Good thread, torunn.


@earl-of-trumps said
This thread could go on and on, but I think it is difficult to talk about the role of man without including
the role of woman, as the way I see it, the two must work together to successfully grow a village.
It's also self evident that men and women have different abilities and the two as a team have all the skills
working for the two (or more) of them.

Good thread, torunn.
That is the ideal situation of course. 🙂


@torunn said
Men's wallets are not an issue we often speak of in this country
No - the judgement is usually silent. But harsh, all the same.

2 edits

@earl-of-trumps said
This thread could go on and on, but I think it is difficult to talk about the role of man without including
the role of woman, as the way I see it, the two must work together to successfully grow a village.
It's also self evident that men and women have different abilities and the two as a team have all the skills
working for the two (or more) of them.

Good thread, torunn.
Agreed Earl excellent thread.

I think you summed it up well.

The woman and man must work together lean on each other at times to make it work.

As torunn has stated times have changed and both the woman and man have to work to make ends meet in many cases.

There use to be an expression: "it takes a village to raise a child"! I believe there is a lot of truth to that saying.

-VR


@very-rusty said
Agreed Earl excellent thread.

I think you summed it up well.

The women and man must work together lean on each other at times to make it work.

As torunn has stated times have changed and both the woman and man have to work to make ends meet in many cases.

There use to be an expression: "it takes a village to raise a child"! I believe their is a lot of truth to that saying.

-VR
Very wise expression, it all starts with the upbringing.


1 edit

Be a man comes from the days of gender rolls. It has a meaning, but that meaning has been rejected by Western Societies in general so does not really having meaning anymore.

What has it traditionally meant? Different things to different people.

Personally, I believe it used to mean shut up and get the job done, it does not matter if you are hurt or not.

Some people believe it means to beat up the other person with your fists.

I think the Dutch had the saying "Man at night, Man in the morning". It had to do with getting drunk and functioning the next day.

1 edit

@very-rusty said
I believe manly means having courage and strength. Correct me if I am wrong but would a woman not want a man to have both of these qualities? Integrity of course would be up there on the list for sure!

-VR
By calling these (courage, strength and integrity) "manly" qualities, are you saying that women do not, or cannot, or should not, display them?

I would think that men would want women to have these qualities as well, but perusing these forums, maybe not.


@suzianne said
By calling these (courage, strength and integrity) "manly" qualities, are you saying that women do not, or cannot, or should not, display them?

I would think that men would want women to have these qualities as well, but perusing these forums, maybe not.
There is potentially an unresolvable conflict within this idea. Not because the idea is wrong imo, but because sometimes there is no right answer.

If you want men to view a quality as manly within your culture (e.g. integrity from Torunn's post) do you automatically create a different problem by inferring it is not equally possible in women. Is it possibly for a culture to view a quality as manly without harming the perception of women in the culture?