Go back
Fishing.

Fishing.

General

L

Joined
08 Mar 03
Moves
13753
Clock
11 May 03
4 edits
Vote Up
Vote Down

I understand there are a few organisations in this world that believe fishing should be banned. This has become more pressing in the face of recent scientific evidence which suggests fish may indeed feel pain.

Personally I do not fish and never have.
However I have spoken to anglers and my general impression of them is that on the whole the do more good than harm. For instance in the monitoring of water quality etc.

My point though is this; If fishing is eventually banned, how long after this will someone be telling me I can no longer eat meat.. I fear this is the direction we are heading towards?

U

Steelers Country

Joined
12 Apr 02
Moves
32833
Clock
11 May 03
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Lazaraus
I understand there are a few organisations in this world that believe fishing should be banned. This has become more pressing in the face of recent scientific evidence which suggests fish may indeed feel pain.

Personally I do not fish and never have.
However I have spoken to anglers and my general impression of them is that on the whole the do more good ...[text shortened]... ne be telling me I can no longer eat meat.. I fear this is the direction we are heading towards?
I wouldnt worry about it, there are probly some organisation somewhere to ban just about anything, just because fish feel pain doesnt mean we cant fish for them to eat. cows and pig...etc... feel pain but as long as we eat them it shouldnt be a problem. now if your being crule to them its another story.
dont worry it wont be banned, neither will meat.

C
Not Aleister

Control room

Joined
17 Apr 02
Moves
91813
Clock
12 May 03
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

It's taken us centuries to claw our way to the top of he food chain...
Why go back now?

pradtf

VeggieChess

Joined
03 Jun 02
Moves
7483
Clock
12 May 03
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Crowley
It's taken us centuries to claw our way to the top of he food chain...
Why go back now?
i always understood it was cannibals who reached the highest rung on the food chain.

perhaps we are going back.

n

Who could tell?

Joined
05 Feb 03
Moves
826
Clock
12 May 03
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Lazaraus
I understand there are a few organisations in this world that believe fishing should be banned. This has become more pressing in the face of recent scientific evidence which suggests fish may indeed feel pain.

Personally I do not fish and never have.
However I have spoken to anglers and my general impression of them is that on the whole the do more good ...[text shortened]... ne be telling me I can no longer eat meat.. I fear this is the direction we are heading towards?
lol, i heard about that, they injected poison into the fish and found that it reacted with muscle spasms and started to flounder.

pain or toxic shock?

the experinebt needs to be redone without the use of chemicals

U

Steelers Country

Joined
12 Apr 02
Moves
32833
Clock
12 May 03
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by nktwild
lol, i heard about that, they injected poison into the fish and found that it reacted with muscle spasms and started to flounder.

pain or toxic shock?

the experinebt needs to be redone without the use of chemicals
now why would they do that? its crule, how would they like it if some fish came up and injected poison into them?😉

but really dont they think that killing it would help the fish?! I mean its ineateble after you poison it, so you cant eat it, it just goes to waste😠

n

Who could tell?

Joined
05 Feb 03
Moves
826
Clock
12 May 03
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by UncleAdam
now why would they do that? its crule, how would they like it if some fish came up and injected poison into them?
done for the same reason as to why religious groups kill each other, some people will do anything to get notice.
You just know these kind of people were bullied at school.

d

Canberra, Australia

Joined
07 Jan 03
Moves
19005
Clock
12 May 03
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by nktwild
done for the same reason as to why religious groups kill each other, some people will do anything to get notice.
You just know these kind of people were bullied at school.
noooo, they did it because if they can prove that fish feel pain perhaps less people would do it. a few fish injected is nothing compared to the amount that you or any other meat eater would throw out because they're not hungry that dinner time.

L

Joined
08 Mar 03
Moves
13753
Clock
12 May 03
Vote Up
Vote Down

I think they actually injected bee sting venom into the fish's lips.
I suppose the premise being that if they reacted to this then they would also feel pain due to a fishing hook.

Experiment was stupid in my opinion, particularly with the concentration levels used in the injection.

N

Joined
10 Apr 03
Moves
181
Clock
12 May 03
Vote Up
Vote Down

Well im an angler, and i have beleive it or not i never knew that fish didnt/did feel pain. i fish becuase i enjoy it and i find it relaxing in this all to hectic world we live in. it gives me a chance to get away from tvs, phones, people and all the noise. there is much controversity about the world of shooting aswell. this is another thing that i partake in. When out shooting it gives the members of the shoot a chance to shoot birds that are all eaten ( so its just like getting meat out of the supermarket) but also we make sure the area that we shoot in is well looked after. this means planting new trees getting rid of the old dead ones and building pens to keep the birds away from predators.


my point is that "sports" such as shooting and fishing are more concerned with conservation than killing

o
Looooney Ork

A galaxy far away

Joined
25 Feb 03
Moves
8046
Clock
12 May 03
Vote Up
Vote Down

When my friends go on fishing trips they always throw the fish back once they've caught them and they don't use sharp hooks so it gives the fish minimal damage. I think it's okay to catch fish and eat them or throw them back. Otherwise it's just a waste.

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.