@wolfgang59 said
Did they?
Did they really?
Was it amazing?
Surely this belongs in Debates?
Or Science?
On the contrary.
The OP is neither debating nor inviting debate whether the event was faked, nor debating whether it was amazing, nor discussing the scientific technicalities of its machinations. So no it doesn’t belong in either a forum for “debates” nor a forum for “science”.
Furthermore I think it is clear that within the context of RHP the “Debates”(n) forum is generally accepted by the public forum contributors to be where matters of a political theme are “debated”(sic) and that, again generally speaking, the restriction of political matters to the “Debates” forum is deemed to be a sort of unwritten forum rule the adherence of which benefits the other forums, especially this General forum, with the absence of the somewhat depressing head-banging which typifies political debate here at RHP.
I suppose one could argue that the OP of this thread belongs in the thread “On this day” although not really as the thread author subsequently and immediately followed the opening post with a subtopic highlighting a historical nuance of the event and an inferred assertion that history had assigned a misquotation. I guess one could argue, if one was of a pedantic nature, that the second post was inviting debate of sorts although the subtopic requires little of it, as it is in fact well documented and the quote correctly ascribed.
In summing up I assert that this thread is ideal General Forum fodder, and in regards to political topics I would lean heavily on the ubiquitous euphemism
“take it to debates spanky.