Go back
Has Esperanto succeeded or failed?

Has Esperanto succeeded or failed?

General

I

Club 64

Joined
03 Sep 06
Moves
1437
Clock
26 Aug 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Right now, I don't think so...but that's just my opinion...

AThousandYoung
1st Dan TKD Kukkiwon

tinyurl.com/2te6yzdu

Joined
23 Aug 04
Moves
26751
Clock
26 Aug 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Ironstar
Right now, I don't think so...but that's just my opinion...
You failed to successfully answer your own question.

That takes talent.

I

Club 64

Joined
03 Sep 06
Moves
1437
Clock
26 Aug 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

lol...I mean that I think it's failed....that it hasn't succeeded...

I

Club 64

Joined
03 Sep 06
Moves
1437
Clock
26 Aug 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Does anyone else think that it's failed...if not, why?

t

my island

Joined
10 Nov 05
Moves
17944
Clock
26 Aug 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by AThousandYoung
You failed to successfully answer your own question.

That takes talent.
almost rec worthy

DS

Joined
22 Aug 05
Moves
26450
Clock
26 Aug 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Ironstar
Does anyone else think that it's failed...if not, why?
How can you tell?

AThousandYoung
1st Dan TKD Kukkiwon

tinyurl.com/2te6yzdu

Joined
23 Aug 04
Moves
26751
Clock
26 Aug 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Ironstar
Does anyone else think that it's failed...if not, why?
It's a language. Can a language have an objective which it can fail at?

r

Joined
09 Jul 04
Moves
198660
Clock
26 Aug 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

of course...it is called communication...

w
If Theres Hell Below

We're All Gonna Go!

Joined
10 Sep 05
Moves
10228
Clock
26 Aug 07
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by AThousandYoung
It's a language. Can a language have an objective which it can fail at?
didn't esperanto have exactly that? as I recall, the whole idea was for it to become a 'big' language, a 'lingua franca', in which it miserably failed.

M

Joined
31 Jan 07
Moves
93899
Clock
26 Aug 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

sadly, Hollywood, the airline travel industry, and the Internet between them succeeded in turning low-standard English into the lingua franca displacing all attempts to get a neutral one, so Esperanto has become a hobby language only, like ancient Botswanan or whatever; and English has had to dumb itself down to words of fewer than 4 syllables and anything-goes spelling, grammar and punctuation.

"From clogs to clogs in three generations"

P
Upward Spiral

Halfway

Joined
02 Aug 04
Moves
8702
Clock
26 Aug 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by MissOleum
sadly, Hollywood, the airline travel industry, and the Internet between them succeeded in turning low-standard English into the lingua franca displacing all attempts to get a neutral one, so Esperanto has become a hobby language only, like ancient Botswanan or whatever; and English has had to dumb itself down to words of fewer than 4 syllables and anything-goes spelling, grammar and punctuation.

"From clogs to clogs in three generations"
You're deluded if you think non-native speakers are to blame for this. Just take a look at this forum.

M

Joined
31 Jan 07
Moves
93899
Clock
26 Aug 07
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

I don't think non-native speakers are to blame at all - if anything, their English is more likely to be correct.

I think Political Correctness is to blame - we can't criticise our own kids' English because that's discrimination in some form, against youth, against people with "learning difficulties" or "psychosocial disadvantages" or whatever. And I know this post will attract the usual criticism from the usual suspects who think everything is a joke and nothing matters except their own egos. Now, where's my broomstick? 😛

N

The sky

Joined
05 Apr 05
Moves
10385
Clock
26 Aug 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by MissOleum
I don't think non-native speakers are to blame at all - if anything, their English is more likely to be correct.

I think Political Correctness is to blame - we can't criticise our own kids' English because that's discrimination in some form, against youth, against people with "learning difficulties" or "psychosocial disadvantages" or whatever. And I ...[text shortened]... hing matters except their own egos. Now, perhaps I should move this to Debates ... 😞
I fail to see the connection between your two posts. How would a success of Esperanto as a lingua franca have prevented the political correctness that you blame for the decline of the English language?

Another thing worth mentioning is that the same thing seems to happen in at least some countries with other native languages. I blame the schools.

P
Upward Spiral

Halfway

Joined
02 Aug 04
Moves
8702
Clock
26 Aug 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Nordlys
I blame the schools.
Burn 'Em!!!

N

The sky

Joined
05 Apr 05
Moves
10385
Clock
26 Aug 07
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Palynka
Burn 'Em!!!
I am working on it.

Edit: I should have said "I blame education", as some countries allow home education with often far worse results

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.