Go back
Ipod or Iriver

Ipod or Iriver

General

Vote Up
Vote Down

I'm thinking of buying an MP3 player but can't decide whether iPod or iRiver would be best. Any tips?

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by asromacalcio
I'm thinking of buying an MP3 player but can't decide whether iPod or iRiver would be best. Any tips?
Go Creative Zen instead.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Starrman
Go Creative Zen instead.
May well do, if you tell me what it is.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Starrman
Go Creative Zen instead.
I have one and they are very good

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by asromacalcio
May well do, if you tell me what it is.
http://www.creative.com/products/welcome.asp?category=213

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Starrman
http://www.creative.com/products/welcome.asp?category=213
They look good, I'd ideally like something around 10GB, with voice recorder and if possible, something about the same dimensions as an iPod mini.

Any more tips?

Vote Up
Vote Down

I'm also being told that the Cowan X5 is good.

Now I'm getting confused.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by asromacalcio
They look good, I'd ideally like something around 10GB, with voice recorder and if possible, something about the same dimensions as an iPod mini.

Any more tips?
don't get an iPod nano - 'nano' refers to the amount of time in seconds that it takes for the thing to break.

Vote Up
Vote Down

I do hear a lot about iPods being naff, just trendy, which is the only reason they sell. My friends have iPods in the main but the ones with iRivers tend to be happier with the product.

Creative Zen is a new one on me but at the moment top of the list is a Cowon X5 20GB thingy.

Anybody know anything about them?

Thanks for all the advice.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Starrman
Creative Zen
Absolutely crap.

I got one, and I had a nightmare trying to connect it to the pc, then the database kept corrupting. In the end, I had to get an Ipod. Mine isn't an isolated case, either.

D

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by asromacalcio
I'm thinking of buying an MP3 player but can't decide whether iPod or iRiver would be best. Any tips?
iPod! By default. Period.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by asromacalcio
I'm thinking of buying an MP3 player but can't decide whether iPod or iRiver would be best. Any tips?
I bought an iRiver HP120 (20G) about 2 years ago, because it came top in a computer magazine round up, beating the iPod. It's absolutely great, with a very useful voice recorder (very clear sound on the built-in mic with the option of plugging a mic in) and an FM radio, and drag-and-drop to add files. They also update the firmware periodically which you can download from their website, giving you extra features. I have used it nearly constantly for those two years and the battery shows no signs of giving up yet (it also lasts for a whole day between charges). I'm not sure how good the models they now sell are, they do seem to do well in comparisons but the iPod and Creative players tend to come top now.

Isn't there some kind of issue with iPods where you can't copy the music from them, only to them? I may be wrong, and I'm sure someone will put me straight. But I use my player for other files as I still have only managed to half fill it.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by mosquitorespect
I bought an iRiver HP120 (20G) about 2 years ago, because it came top in a computer magazine round up, beating the iPod. It's absolutely great, with a very useful voice recorder (very clear sound on the built-in mic with the option of plugging a mic in) and an FM radio, and drag-and-drop to add files. They also update the firmware periodically whic ...[text shortened]... traight. But I use my player for other files as I still have only managed to half fill it.
You can copy from them, but it messes up the filenames and doesn't retain the directory structure (relying on ID3 info to arrange the songs).

The biggest downer about them is the lack of ability to change the battery, unless you pay €60 odd extra for an external battery pack. Also, the battery only lasts a certain length of time, after which you have to send it to apple to change, at a cost.

I had an iRiver mp3 cd player in 2003, and it was great. I don't know anything about their more recent products though.

D

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Ragnorak
Absolutely crap.

I got one, and I had a nightmare trying to connect it to the pc, then the database kept corrupting. In the end, I had to get an Ipod. Mine isn't an isolated case, either.

D
Mine works like a dream and I have friends whose ipods have done exactly what you just described... I was merely making a reccomendation on my own experience.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Starrman
I was merely making a reccomendation on my own experience.
Read what I quoted.

And, by the way, if you were a Bond villain, you'd be called Auric Brownfinger, and your masterplan would be to blow up Fort Kox, to make men everywhere seek out your brown (stained) "gun".

D