Go back
Niemann Cheating Accusations Lawsuit - Dismissed

Niemann Cheating Accusations Lawsuit - Dismissed

General


A US federal judge on Tuesday dismissed a lawsuit filed by chess player Hans Niemann, who was seeking $100 million from those who accused him of cheating, including former world champion Magnus Carlsen.



https://sports.yahoo.com/us-judge-throws-high-profile-014049175.html

Vote Up
Vote Down

Yeah, I thought that lawsuit was idiotic.

2 edits
Vote Up
Vote Down

Well, they could not back up their cries of "cheating", there's the problem.

However, in this case where Niemann had been caught cheating 100 times before (online and chess.com),
then these new cries of the same-old did no harm to his reputation. I'm just grappling for excuses, actually.
I really think Neimann's case should have gone forward.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@earl-of-trumps said
Well, they could not back up their cries of "cheating", there's the problem.

However, in this case where Niemann had been caught cheating 100 times before (online and chess.com),
then these new cries of the same-old did no harm to his reputation. I'm just grappling for excuses, actually.
I really think Neimann's case should have gone forward.
Thanks for posting and I agree.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Nemann had no case. Magnus and Chess.com released a lengthy statement outlining their evidence for Neiman cheating.

That's on top of Nakamura's pretty damning analysis of Neiman's awkward interview where could not adequately explain his move choices in a post-game interview of his game against Magnus.

Suing for defamation only has merit if it can be shown the accused knew their statements were false. That's clearly not the case here.

1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

I understand Niemann got mauled by Zaven Andriasian right after

Vote Up
Vote Down

@vivify said - Suing for defamation only has merit if it can be shown the accused knew their statements were false.
-------------------------------------------------------

That is something I did not know. thanks

Vote Up
Vote Down

@gambrel said
I understand Niemann got mauled by Zaven Andriasian right after
That tournament was intense.

Niemann was the lowest rated player at 2700/ amazing

Vote Up
Vote Down

@vivify said
Nemann had no case. Magnus and Chess.com released a lengthy statement outlining their evidence for Neiman cheating.

That's on top of Nakamura's pretty damning analysis of Neiman's awkward interview where could not adequately explain his move choices in a post-game interview of his game against Magnus.

Suing for defamation only has merit if it can be shown the accused knew their statements were false. That's clearly not the case here.
Maybe then, the real question is... how did he do it, and why did he get "mauled" by someone in the game right after the Carlson win?

It all seems very strange to me.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@earl-of-trumps said
@vivify said - Suing for defamation only has merit if it can be shown the accused knew their statements were false.
-------------------------------------------------------

That is something I did not know. thanks
The reason you did not know it is because it is not true.
Defamation is making a false statement about someone that is likely to cause them harm.

Vote Up
Vote Down

My perspective on this whole affair is different. I see it through the prism of having an 1127 rating.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@the-gravedigger said
The reason you did not know it is because it is not true.
Defamation is making a false statement about someone that is likely to cause them harm.
merci, again 🙂

Vote Up
Vote Down

Much has been said of a rumored cage fight Musk vs Zuckerberg. I wanna see Calsen vs Neimann

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.