Go back
Puzzler

Puzzler

General

kyngj

42.4º N / -71.2º W

Joined
11 Jun 01
Moves
90620
Clock
31 Aug 02
Vote Up
Vote Down

OK everyone, since Genius decided to give us a puzzle, thought I'd give you one of my
own....

So if you've heard this one before, don't speak up, and if you haven't, think about it, don't
use the internet to get the answer, that's no fun now is it...;-)

Alright - you're in a waiting room with 99 other people, to make 100 in total. You're all told
that once you go into the next room, you'll be placed in single file line facing forward, such
that the guy at the back can see everyone in front of him, and the guy at the front of the line
can see no-one. Got that?

Once you're in this second room, you each get a hat put on your head, which is either black
or white. You can NOT see your own hat, but you can see the hat colour of everyone in front
of you, and not behind. (So, the guy in the middle of the line can see the hats of the 49 in
front of him, but not the 50 behind him.)

Once the hats have been placed on the heads, a guy with a gun goes to the back of the line
and points it to the head of the last guy in the line. The person can say either black or white,
and if they get their own hat colour correct, they survive, if not, they die. The person cannot
say anything else except black or white, just ONE word, and they have to get their own hat
colour correct to live. Once the outcome of that happens, the man with the gun goes to the
next person in line, and so on, until he reaches the front of the line.

OK, here is the question, what strategy can you come up with in the waiting room that will
save the most number of people GUARANTEED??

I'll give you a hint, you can save 99 of the people guaranteed....

Enjoy,

Joe

H

Joined
08 Jul 02
Moves
2519
Clock
31 Aug 02
Vote Up
Vote Down

Well considering I've never heard this puzzle before, I would think
that the most appropriate form would be for the guy at the back (with
the gun) to sacrifice himself!
It's probably wrong but it was good trying even though I am real bored!

kyngj

42.4º N / -71.2º W

Joined
11 Jun 01
Moves
90620
Clock
31 Aug 02
Vote Up
Vote Down

Good effort, although the guy with the gun is not one of the hundred!

Rhymester
and RedHotTed

Red Hot Rebel Clan

Joined
06 Apr 01
Moves
235718
Clock
31 Aug 02
Vote Up
Vote Down

That's very clever! I've figured it out but won't spoil it for others... but
I will give one really big clue - I wouldn't want to be the guy at the
back of the line! ;-)

Rhymester

S
The Diplomat

Slightly Left :D

Joined
22 Jun 01
Moves
8518
Clock
31 Aug 02
Vote Up
Vote Down

Yep!!

Beck got it before me...but that is right!

Dave

kyngj

42.4º N / -71.2º W

Joined
11 Jun 01
Moves
90620
Clock
31 Aug 02
Vote Up
Vote Down

What is right? Come on guys, talk it out, you might not have it for sure you know! ;-)

Joe
Criticising as ever...

bbarr
Chief Justice

Center of Contention

Joined
14 Jun 02
Moves
17381
Clock
31 Aug 02
Vote Up
Vote Down

The person in the very back answers according to the rule:

when questioned, give the color of the hat directly in front of you.

The nest person will thus know the color of their own hat. They, in
turn will answer according to these rules:

If the person directly in front of you has a hat color corresponding to
the answer of the person in back of you, then repeat the answer.

If their hat is a different color answer as before only shout the answer
loudly.

If the person in back of you shouts their answer, then answer with the
hat color opposite the one they just gave.

kyngj

42.4º N / -71.2º W

Joined
11 Jun 01
Moves
90620
Clock
31 Aug 02
Vote Up
Vote Down

I forgot to stipulate that you can't shout - That would work, but there is a more elegant
solution out there....

Joe

coyote

Joined
08 Jul 02
Moves
155018
Clock
31 Aug 02
Vote Up
Vote Down

What else can't be done? I have a thought, but it might not be
allowed: Although only one word can be said, can anything else be
done? For instance, switching hats?

Coyote

kyngj

42.4º N / -71.2º W

Joined
11 Jun 01
Moves
90620
Clock
31 Aug 02
Vote Up
Vote Down

Nope, you can't do anything but say the one word - check Sin's reply,
he got it really quickly...

Joe

S
The Diplomat

Slightly Left :D

Joined
22 Jun 01
Moves
8518
Clock
31 Aug 02
Vote Up
Vote Down

Booyah!! Way to go Bennet!! same thing we had....and the damn
dogs are up...are you watching??

Dave

bbarr
Chief Justice

Center of Contention

Joined
14 Jun 02
Moves
17381
Clock
31 Aug 02
Vote Up
Vote Down

Down by one. Can't complain. That Imperial pint of Guinness is going
to go down so smooth.

s

Joined
01 Dec 01
Moves
14745
Clock
31 Aug 02
Vote Up
Vote Down

can I have a shot? the last one is in danger : 50% chance.
He doesn't know , so for him, both colors are equally good.
They agree in the waiting room that he will call 'white' if he sees an
even number of whites in front of him. Regardless of what happens
to him, the others can make the sustraction. Theys just call their
color, making the even/odd count right with what they heard and see,
and their own.

Is that about right? sin

kyngj

42.4º N / -71.2º W

Joined
11 Jun 01
Moves
90620
Clock
31 Aug 02
Vote Up
Vote Down

Perfect Sin, I'm very impressed, it took me a day and a half of hard
thinking to come by that one.... good work!

Joe

Acolyte
Now With Added BA

Loughborough

Joined
04 Jul 02
Moves
3790
Clock
02 Sep 02
Vote Up
Vote Down

I've seen this problem before, and it was referred to as the "Saddam Hussein problem".
where Saddam had buried 100 POWs up to their necks in sand, so that they couldn't turn
around. The solution is exactly the one you just said. But... what happens if someone makes
a mistake? How many can you save then?

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.