Go back
Recommendations: The last discussion

Recommendations: The last discussion

General

Vote Up
Vote Down

There have been many things going on at RHP. There was the problem with harrasment, the cussing, etc. Now ther is a lot of discussion about recs. There are many people who keep talking about it in many different ways. Frankly, there's only a few things to say.

The point of the recs are to advance something. When I see people asking for recs, that makes me sad. What makes it even sadder is that then I see 7-9 recs. Look at it this way: If there are 10 pounds of gold in the world, each is worth 1000. If someone finds 90 more pounds, though, the the price drops to about 100 dollors a pound. The same with these recs. If we toss these around like that, then the price and value of these recs take a sharp drop. When I go to the reccomended posts place, I look for things that are worthwhile. I, and I'm sure many agree with me, don't want to see a post saying Rec please with 30 recs. Think of these recs as dollors. Would you give a dollor to someone saying something or to someone saying Give me money cause I want it ?

When you give a rec, think about it. Does this post say someting that ispireds people? If not, reconsider your decison. Make these recs valueful.

End of discussion.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by abejnood
There have been many things going on at RHP. There was the problem with harrasment, the cussing, etc. Now ther is a lot of discussion about recs. There are many people who keep talking about it in many different ways. Frankly, there's only a few things to say.

The point of the recs are to advance something. When I see people asking for recs, that makes ...[text shortened]... pireds people? If not, reconsider your decison. Make these recs valueful.

End of discussion.
it wasn't...

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by abejnood
There have been many things going on at RHP. ....Make these recs valueful.

End of discussion.
I do believe you wanted the word valuable, not valueful.

🙂

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by abejnood
There have been many things going on at RHP. There was the problem with harrasment, the cussing, etc. Now ther is a lot of discussion about recs. There are many people who keep talking about it in many different ways. Frankly, there's only a few things to say.

The point of the recs are to advance something. When I see people asking for recs, that makes ...[text shortened]... pireds people? If not, reconsider your decison. Make these recs valueful.

End of discussion.
Ya know I never thought of it this way. It is way too important to just “give away” valuable recommendations as if they meant nothing at all. I do get very irritated to see such flagrant abuse. It irritates me that some mundane post can get any rec’s at all! This just encourages mediocre posters to continue to think that they are “like sooo much Fonzi”!

RTh

Vote Up
Vote Down

That sure was an ispireing post.

Vote Up
Vote Down

IMHO, recs don't have any value outside of a little ego boost. Therefore, I don't think this thread has any value.

End of discussion.

1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by XanthosNZ
That sure was an ispireing post.
Do I spot a mistake in a post by XanthosNZ?

Edit: orthography I have to admit

1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Ponderable
Do I spot an orthograpgic mistak in a post by XanthosNZ?
Yes.
Did you spot an unintentional mistake? No.
Did you make two of your own in asking me? Yes.

EDIT: Second to last line of OP.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by abejnood
There have been many things going on at RHP. There was the problem with harrasment, the cussing, etc. Now ther is a lot of discussion about recs. There are many people who keep talking about it in many different ways. Frankly, there's only a few things to say.

The point of the recs are to advance something. When I see people asking for recs, that makes ...[text shortened]... pireds people? If not, reconsider your decison. Make these recs valueful.

End of discussion.
What is your suggestion. Limit recs per day/week that can be given?

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by XanthosNZ
Yes.
Did you spot an unintentional mistake? No.
Did you make two of your own in asking me? Yes.

EDIT: Second to last line of OP.
Was "Le Miserables" (sic! ) also an intestinal mistake?

Vote Up
Vote Down

Six recs per day per non-pawn star?

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by KneverKnight
Six recs per day per non-pawn star?
I didn't know there were non-pawn stars. What kind of stars are they? Knight stars?

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Nordlys
I didn't know there were non-pawn stars. What kind of stars are they? Knight stars?
Brown Dwarfs or something.
Very hard to see.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Why not fix the total number of recs in circulation, and allow us to spend our recs on reccing other posts? That way, one only gets recs to spend by being recced, but recs are no longer some sort of badge of honour because they are designed to be lost in spending. Instead, they become both a vehicle for highlighting popular posts and encouraging good posting (since having recs gives one more influence over the 'Recommended' page). Also, hoarding one's recs does little good in theory, because as a widespread phenomenon it would bring reccing to a halt. In practice, there would be no point in doing it because there would be nothing impressive about having lots of recs -- you'd just be a hoarder, in much the same way as it's relatively pointless to carry around large quantities of cash and refuse to spend any when there is an appropriate place to spend it.

1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Coconut
What is your suggestion. Limit recs per day/week that can be given?
Jesus Christ, your avatar is extremely disgusting. Why would you do that?

EDIT: And while I'm thankful for the joystick I have to ask why?

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.