19 Mar 07
Originally posted by wittywonkaI'd say that talking theory is fine.
Almost every time I consider asking about anything in the chess forums, I hesitate for fear of ignorance about what is allowed and what is not. For example, could I ask if mate was possible in a certain endgame if I didn't ask how to do it?
If anything you're discussing is relevant to games you have in progress - then you're asking for trouble. Better to seek analysis of games that have finished than try to work out what would be good in a current game.
Make the mistake - then learn by it. Better than trying to avoid the mistake and getting kicked out for cheating.
Otherwise, there are a lot of very knowledgeable people here, and I'm sure you'll get told what to look for and what not in a given situation.
I never bother asking anyone, only because I never bother examining my games once they're done.
Just my opinion.
21 Mar 07
Originally posted by wittywonkaYou can't ask if mate is possible in a game you are playing here at RHP. That is advice, even if you don't ask how to do it. It's up to you to figure your games on your own.
Almost every time I consider asking about anything in the chess forums, I hesitate for fear of ignorance about what is allowed and what is not. For example, could I ask if mate was possible in a certain endgame if I didn't ask how to do it?
Also, if you ask if it's possible... someone might come in and say, "Yes, and here is how it's done."
If you ask about a position in your RHP game, chances are someone is going to scan your games and see if you are in that position in any of them. That is when you will start to get in trouble for asking about that game. You don't need to ask how it's done to have been helped. The answer is the help, because you will now either play on, or move on to your other games due to outside advice.
P-
25 Mar 07
2 edits
Originally posted by wittywonkaIt is still possible that it would help you in that game - it's also possible that the position could recur. Why not just wait till the game has finished and then ask?
How about this, can you ask for comments/advice on an ongoing game but only on moves that have already been made?
btw: I'm 99.9% sure that the rule is you cannot ask if the game isn't finished.
