23 May '13 14:55>
You lot still discussing this?
What you are looking at after.
1. Nf3 Nf6 2. Ng5 e5 3. Nxf7 Kxf7 4. e4
Is a hybrid version of the Cochrane Gambit v the Petroff a whole tempo down.
1. e4 e5 2. Nf3 Nf6 3. Nxe5 d6 4. Nxf7 Kxf7
White now plays 5.d4 and the fun begins.
back here...
It is Black's move.
SG's decision to swing it into a Pirc with 4..g6 was OK but demanded strict exact play.
4...d5! and if 5.exd5 Bd6.
And the Bishop coming to c4 that worried SG so much is blocked by White's own pawn.
If White goes the Nf3-e5-f7 route so Black does not get in 2...e5.
1. Nf3 Nf6 2. Ne5 d6 3. Nxf7 Kxf7 4. e4 e5
Is similiar to a Philidor set up except Black is a piece ahead.
And if White does not play now play 5.Bc4+ Black is going to play 5...Be6 so:
5.Bc4+ d5! 6.exd5 Bd6.
It's going to take some work to justify that piece sac.
Not 100% sure one should be looking at this type of game with a box.
It will try to hang onto material clogging itself up steering the human
towards a position that will be difficult to play.
A good human will be looking to throw the bit back at the right moment
to either expose the White King or pick up his two pawns with a sure plus.
A box won't go this way, it will see it, judge it good and playable
but that consideration will be way down the scale.
And don't worry about 1.Nf3 it's often played at this level by players
wishing to avoid theory or go for a Black defence in reverse.
Go for a KID safe in the knowledge you will not be getting one of the
sharp f4 lines or the Samisch (5.f3).
or
1...Nc6 and play the Chigorin if 2.d4.
or
1...Nf6 and knock the ball back to him and if 2.g3 then 2....b5
(yes not a typo. 2...b5)
Not worry about it.
If it was any good Fischer would have played 1.Nf3 in every game.
Don't forget Reti himsefl gave up the Reti.
In 1928 four years after it appeared Reti as White played 1.e4 12 times,
1 d4 12 times, a couple of 1.c4's and no 1.Nf3's.
What you are looking at after.
1. Nf3 Nf6 2. Ng5 e5 3. Nxf7 Kxf7 4. e4
Is a hybrid version of the Cochrane Gambit v the Petroff a whole tempo down.
1. e4 e5 2. Nf3 Nf6 3. Nxe5 d6 4. Nxf7 Kxf7
White now plays 5.d4 and the fun begins.
back here...
It is Black's move.
SG's decision to swing it into a Pirc with 4..g6 was OK but demanded strict exact play.
4...d5! and if 5.exd5 Bd6.
And the Bishop coming to c4 that worried SG so much is blocked by White's own pawn.
If White goes the Nf3-e5-f7 route so Black does not get in 2...e5.
1. Nf3 Nf6 2. Ne5 d6 3. Nxf7 Kxf7 4. e4 e5
Is similiar to a Philidor set up except Black is a piece ahead.
And if White does not play now play 5.Bc4+ Black is going to play 5...Be6 so:
5.Bc4+ d5! 6.exd5 Bd6.
It's going to take some work to justify that piece sac.
Not 100% sure one should be looking at this type of game with a box.
It will try to hang onto material clogging itself up steering the human
towards a position that will be difficult to play.
A good human will be looking to throw the bit back at the right moment
to either expose the White King or pick up his two pawns with a sure plus.
A box won't go this way, it will see it, judge it good and playable
but that consideration will be way down the scale.
And don't worry about 1.Nf3 it's often played at this level by players
wishing to avoid theory or go for a Black defence in reverse.
Go for a KID safe in the knowledge you will not be getting one of the
sharp f4 lines or the Samisch (5.f3).
or
1...Nc6 and play the Chigorin if 2.d4.
or
1...Nf6 and knock the ball back to him and if 2.g3 then 2....b5
(yes not a typo. 2...b5)
Not worry about it.
If it was any good Fischer would have played 1.Nf3 in every game.
Don't forget Reti himsefl gave up the Reti.
In 1928 four years after it appeared Reti as White played 1.e4 12 times,
1 d4 12 times, a couple of 1.c4's and no 1.Nf3's.