Go back
Baboons (aka Is Chess a Sport?)

Baboons (aka Is Chess a Sport?)

Only Chess

DF

Joined
18 Feb 10
Moves
0
Clock
22 Sep 15
Vote Up
Vote Down

From http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-34323643

Chess grandmasters use between 6,000 and 7,000 calories a day when competing, Robert Sapolsky, professor of neurology at Stanford University, has said. They are "turning on a massive physiological stress response simply with thought and doing the same thing with their bodies as if they were some baboon who has just ripped open the stomach of their worst rival and it's all with thought, and memories and emotions".

Personally speaking I don't think chess (or bridge) are sports, but I get a lot of grief from people when I express that opinion as we in the UK need chess to be classified as a sport in order to get more (i.e. any) funding.

greenpawn34

e4

Joined
06 May 08
Moves
43363
Clock
22 Sep 15
Vote Up
Vote Down

Hi Data Fly,

I've see valid arguments both for against Chess being classed as sport.

I'd not class it as a sport but it needs to get classed as a sport for the funding.
Pastimes do not get funding, art does but is chess an art?

G

santa cruz, ca.

Joined
19 Jul 13
Moves
376505
Clock
22 Sep 15

I would classify chess as a sport only if the minimum weight of each piece was 5 pounds

s
Fast and Curious

slatington, pa, usa

Joined
28 Dec 04
Moves
53321
Clock
28 Sep 15
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by lemondrop
I would classify chess as a sport only if the minimum weight of each piece was 5 pounds
Find any neutrino's yet?

w

Joined
22 Mar 11
Moves
45985
Clock
28 Sep 15
Vote Up
Vote Down

Sport "an activity involving physical exertion and skill in which an individual or team competes against another or others for entertainment."

Chess does not involve 'physical' exertion. While one does move the pieces, presumably at some point that physical movement could be replaced by a mind controlled event. Perhaps blitz chess, where the speed of the movements becomes a factor could be considered a sport.

vandervelde

Joined
10 Dec 11
Moves
143494
Clock
29 Sep 15
Vote Up
Vote Down

Brain is body hence it´s physical.
I admit chess players (some of them all right) look more intellectual and nerdy than darts players, but some chess players really sweat much.
Their pants looks (and smell) like sumo wrestlers´ mawashi, as in one Austin Powers movie.

vandervelde

Joined
10 Dec 11
Moves
143494
Clock
29 Sep 15
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by wsossin
Sport "an activity involving physical exertion and skill in which an individual or team competes against another or others for entertainment."

Chess does not involve 'physical' exertion. While one does move the pieces, presumably at some point that physical movement could be replaced by a mind controlled event. Perhaps blitz chess, where the speed of the movements becomes a factor could be considered a sport.
Damned. I just saw in your profile that you're a neuroscientist!
At least you are not my brain surgeon so I can live with it if you are mad.

w

Joined
22 Mar 11
Moves
45985
Clock
29 Sep 15
Vote Up
Vote Down

I think its more a philosophical question than a neuroscience one. What exactly does 'physical' mean.

G

santa cruz, ca.

Joined
19 Jul 13
Moves
376505
Clock
29 Sep 15
1 edit

an activity is not a sport if you can consume a 5 course meal at the same time

edit: if chess were classified as a sport then reading a book would also be

G

santa cruz, ca.

Joined
19 Jul 13
Moves
376505
Clock
29 Sep 15

Originally posted by sonhouse
Find any neutrino's yet?
I've caught a couple by surprise

Steve45
Mozart

liverpool

Joined
24 May 12
Moves
30766
Clock
29 Sep 15
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

I would say that any game that has world class players and world class tournaments has to be classified as sport. How can anyone say that snooker and darts are sports, but chess is not? I don't agree that sport has to be something that has physical exertion.

G

santa cruz, ca.

Joined
19 Jul 13
Moves
376505
Clock
29 Sep 15
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Steve45
I would say that any game that has world class players and world class tournaments has to be classified as sport. How can anyone say that snooker and darts are sports, but chess is not? I don't agree that sport has to be something that has physical exertion.
if you go by the dictionary definition, sport involves physical exertion otherwise, the simple burning of calories could be defined as sport

Steve45
Mozart

liverpool

Joined
24 May 12
Moves
30766
Clock
29 Sep 15
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by lemondrop
if you go by the dictionary definition, sport involves physical exertion otherwise, the simple burning of calories could be defined as sport
But that means you can't call snooker an darts sport. But they are called sports.

Tintin1963

Joined
24 Apr 10
Moves
23328
Clock
29 Sep 15
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Steve45
But that means you can't call snooker an darts sport. But they are called sports.
Quite simply, a sport is anything that requires specialist footwear. Think about all major sports globally [Except swimming/diving and other water based sports].
So snooker and darts are NOT sports...and...certainly not Chess or Bridge, lol!

G

santa cruz, ca.

Joined
19 Jul 13
Moves
376505
Clock
29 Sep 15

Originally posted by Steve45
But that means you can't call snooker an darts sport. But they are called sports.
I would define those as activities
I'm a throwback to the ancient Greek Olympics where a sporting event was all physical
I don't think that debating, which they were good at, would have been considered sport even though by your definition it would be

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.