Hi everyone,
I wanted to get some input from you on what you might call 'positional' openings. I'm not looking for an easy-way-out, offbeat system to trick opponents, but rather a solid repertoire. I just seem to enjoy those long, drawn out battles that come down to an endgame. I've recently begun playing the English as white, and I really enjoy the positions that arise. As Black vs. 1.d4 I am thinking of the Slav because it is also playable against the Reti and the English (as opposed to the Nimzo/QID). Against 1.e4, I've been playing the Caro Kann, and I like it quite a bit. I also like the positional nature of the Spanish as black, but with 1...e5 I'm generally facing some other opening. Putting the time in to learn the Ruy only to use it in a small percentage of games seems inefficient. Are there any other 1.e4 defenses that I might consider?
Thanks for any advice,
Scott
If you want relatively closed positions you could try e6 (french) d6(pirc) or c6( caro-cann). Of those I think the weakest is the pirc so I'd suggest the other two more emphatically. Pick one and get good at it, people won't know what to do when you play it and you'll have the upper hand. Of course you, and your opponents can use opening databases but for some reason most people don't.
Originally posted by smrex13You can do almost anything against 1.e4 with the Caro. Lots of different positions available to you there, but most depend on what white plays early on. So you'd need to learn all of the variations. The Caro ain't easy, but if you like cramped and long struggles and have the patience for that sort of thing it's perfect. It's not easy to get a win against good players with it, but it's tough to take a loss without great play from your opponent.
Hi everyone,
I wanted to get some input from you on what you might call 'positional' openings. I'm not looking for an easy-way-out, offbeat system to trick opponents, but rather a solid repertoire. I just seem to enjoy those long, drawn out battles that come down to an endgame. I've recently begun playing the English as white, and I really enjoy th ...[text shortened]... t. Are there any other 1.e4 defenses that I might consider?
Thanks for any advice,
Scott
Botvinnik's Caro-Kann games are an excellent resource.
You should definitely go with the Slav if you're playing the Caro. You'll see similiar positions arise quite often and Black's counter attacking opportunities are also similiar. Not all of course, but some.
Originally posted by smrex13While it is a departure from your other choices you might have some luck with the Sicilian Najorf.
Hi everyone,
I wanted to get some input from you on what you might call 'positional' openings. I'm not looking for an easy-way-out, offbeat system to trick opponents, but rather a solid repertoire. I just seem to enjoy those long, drawn out battles that come down to an endgame. I've recently begun playing the English as white, and I really enjoy th ...[text shortened]... t. Are there any other 1.e4 defenses that I might consider?
Thanks for any advice,
Scott
Originally posted by smrex13If you want a solid game you should play the Queens Gambit, The French defence and the kings or nimzo indian
Hi everyone,
I wanted to get some input from you on what you might call 'positional' openings. I'm not looking for an easy-way-out, offbeat system to trick opponents, but rather a solid repertoire. I just seem to enjoy those long, d ...[text shortened]... efenses that I might consider?
Thanks for any advice,
Scott
[While it is a departure from your other choices you might have some luck with the Sicilian Najorf.[/b]I was wondering about the Sicilian. Everyone always calls the Sicilian a fighting, counterattacking defense, but I know that there are positional Sicilians as well. Is the Najdorf an extremely positional variation? Are there other variations that are more positional?
Thanks for everyone's replies,
Scott
Originally posted by LordOfTheChessboard
If you want a solid game you should play the Queens Gambit, The French defence and the kings or nimzo indian
But the problem is that White can't force a Queen's Gambit. Often, he winds up in a Benoni or Grunfeld, which is the type of position I was trying to avoid.
Originally posted by smrex13I've always known the Najorf as a positionally based opening compared to say the counterattacking tactics of the Dragon.
I was wondering about the Sicilian. Everyone always calls the Sicilian a fighting, counterattacking defense, but I know that there are positional Sicilians as well. Is the Najdorf an extremely positional variation? Are there other variations that are more positional?
Thanks for everyone's replies,
Scott
Of course I'm sure one of the resident Najorf experts can dig out some aggressive tactical lines in it but I think overall it is positional.
Originally posted by XanthosNZI think the Najdorf is extremely tactical. I think most sicilians is. Just tkae the Sozin attack, which is based on many tactics, and there are also the Bg5 line with all its Nd5 sacs.
I've always known the Najorf as a positionally based opening compared to say the counterattacking tactics of the Dragon.
Of course I'm sure one of the resident Najorf experts can dig out some aggressive tactical lines in it but I think overall it is positional.
So i think tactics play a big role in most sicilians.