Please turn on javascript in your browser to play chess.
Only Chess Forum

Only Chess Forum

  1. Donation ketchuplover
    G.O.A.T.
    17 Apr '18 16:59
    1 point per reachable square + one point per supporting piece - 1 point per defending piece. Thoughts?
  2. Subscriber sonhouse
    Fast and Curious
    17 Apr '18 17:05
    Originally posted by @ketchuplover
    1 point per reachable square + one point per supporting piece - 1 point per defending piece. Thoughts?
    Isn't that just a reformulation of 'space points'? How many points you attack with your pieces on the opponents side of the board? If you count them up as a tally, say white has 10 space points and black has one, it would be easy to see black being in deep doo doo. And of course double trouble if the space points coincide on one opponent square, say f7 or some such.
  3. Subscriber ogb
    18 Apr '18 03:28
    is this how computers assign values?
  4. 18 Apr '18 12:40
    Originally posted by @ketchuplover
    1 point per reachable square + one point per supporting piece - 1 point per defending piece. Thoughts?
    Simplistic. A white knight on e6, supported by one pawn, is rarely worth the same as that same knight on c3 supported by its queen.

    Then again, it's not significantly more simplistic than any other common piece value formula.
  5. Subscriber BigDoggProblem
    The Advanced Mind
    18 Apr '18 18:28
    Originally posted by @shallow-blue
    Simplistic. A white knight on e6, supported by one pawn, is rarely worth the same as that same knight on c3 supported by its queen.

    Then again, it's not significantly more simplistic than any other common piece value formula.
    That formula could fluctuate wildly from move to move as line-moving pieces get blocked and unblocked.
  6. Subscriber venda
    Dave
    18 Apr '18 19:00
    Originally posted by @ketchuplover
    1 point per reachable square + one point per supporting piece - 1 point per defending piece. Thoughts?
    Don't see the point personally.
    There's too many variables particularly in an end game.
    What "value" would you assign to a pawn one square away from queening?