25 Jan '07 17:36>
Originally posted by WulebgrOriginally posted by Wulebgr
Originally posted by techsouth
[b]You want the opposition to occur at the end of your opponents move.
This is the reverse of the definition of opposition. It should be at the end of your move.
If you are on f3 when he is on g5 (rook on a4), when it is your move DO NOT play Kg3. He can then play Kf5 and move all the way toward your rook ...[text shortened]... tered before illustrates all this, although I didn't actually step through it.
It does.[/b]
Originally posted by techsouth
[b]You want the opposition to occur at the end of your opponents move.
This is the reverse of the definition of opposition. It should be at the end of your move.
[/b]
In spite of an apparant squabble about a definition of a word, this describes the mechanism I intend to describe. Perhaps I could more correctly say that you want your opponent to take the opposition. Point being that the kings are in opposition and it is your opponents turn.
More misleading advice.
Rather, keep your king on the same row as your opponent's king until he/she is on the edge of the board. Then, keep your king on the adjacent file.
While there may be other approaches that also work, I don't see how this can be characterized as misleading if it works. I haven't read the book you describe, however I am certain I can checkmate the author if I have a king and rook and he just has a king.
As I pointed out, verbal description is difficult, so perhaps a little more kindness is in order. Nevertheless, your description as written suffers a fatal flaw in that it describes nothing that forces your opponent to move to the edge. You can't wait for him to move to the edge if he is not forced somehow to do so. If you keep moving your king such that it has opposition, he can just move back and forth.
I have no doubt you can checkmate with a king and rook, but kids I have tried to teach have great difficulty mastering this. I've had the most success suggesting they make their opponent take the opposition. Also, I find it personally much easier to focus only on driving to the edge without regard to whether it also is tending toward a corner.