3 edits
After all recent discussions about cheaters and ineffective system to detect them, after all dubious opponents and all cheating paranoia in the air do you trust to anyone on this site anymore ? What is your criteria of determining which player is genuine ?
My graph sure doesn't help me, I received some PMs with engine semi-accusations (formuled more like questions "ya using engine ?" etc.) There is more and more suspicious players, well, I am one of them too.
Somehow I more believe to people active in forums, well known names but that is just my brain playing tricks ; everyone can be potential blatant cheaters, having well known username doesn't stop them.
Does it have any sense to believe to anyone rated above 1800 ?
Originally posted by ivan2908Depends on what your definition of genuine is. To some engine use is a badge of honor, databases, opening books, etc.
After all recent discussions about cheaters and ineffective system to detect them, after all dubious opponents and all cheating paranoia in the air do you trust to anyone on this site anymore ? What is your criteria of determining which player is genuine ?
My graph sure doesn't help me, I received some PMs with engine semi-accusations (formuled more lik ...[text shortened]... sername doesn't stop them.
Does it have any sense to believe to anyone rated above 1800 ?
Originally posted by eldragonflyto some confusion of clear distinctions in the rules is a badge of honor
Depends on what your definition of genuine is. To some engine use is a badge of honor, databases, opening books, etc.
Ivan, yes your graph raises suspicions. But your larger question about trust affects many players. As one that has played on at least a dozen sites similar to this one, and played by postcard before these sites existed. I have also played, and play, by email. Cheating is always a possibility. However, if someone at my level is cheating, he or she is doing it badly.
Originally posted by paultopiaCheaters hurt the clan system. Sure your clan table position is just a number, but it represents the reality of maybe 20 people working together to achive something they can rightfully be proud of and cheaters can take some of that away from them.
Oh, who cares? Who do cheaters hurt, other than themselves?
Cheaters hurt the tournaments. Look at some open-rated tourneys. I want every player to know that they can go as far in the contest as their own abilities allow, if they are 700 or 2000, but cheaters prevent that. Cheaters have won tournaments here at RHP and that does hurt the member who played fairly and came in 2sd.
Cheaters hurt the individual. Yes, a rating is just a number, but it does represent your studies and efforts and it should be a fair representation and cheaters can affect that.
Cheaters hurt RHP. This web site exists in large part because of the $30 yearly subscription members pay. New people may not join and old members may leave if RHP is seen to have a cheating problem.
Back to the original thread question...Do you trust anyone here? Yes I do. I trust every member of my clan (Pooh), I trust everyone I start a game with, and I'll trust anyone here who will simply tell me, "I don't cheat".
Best,
Steve
Originally posted by paultopiaI can tell you the players that have lost tournaments because of the cheater winning them would care very much. I am pretty certain the majority of us here, want to be playing another player, NOT AN ENGINE!
Oh, who cares? That's one not-nice change from when I was here before -- the new fights about cheating. Who do cheaters hurt, other than themselves?
Originally posted by JerryHYep. Almost everything posted in the forums by eldragonfly is wrong, misleading, or simply trolling. He catches me with his crappy bait from time to time, as in this thread.
Please forgive my confusion, are you saying that using databases and opening books during a game is allowed?
Originally posted by ivan2908I surely don't want to play an opponent worth 1750+ but having less than 1100 in rating. If I win, I get one lousy point, if I lose (and the odds favours that it might happen( I lose 30 points. Bad business any way.
My graph sure doesn't help me
But even when you have 1800 and we start a game, who knows where your rating is when we end the game? Your rating history says that I don't want to play with you.
I know, rating is not everything, but for me it is a measurement how good I am. If I not feel like I am not worth the current rating, I do my correction in my head.
Why do you have such a roller coaster rating history, Ivan?