what would you do??

what would you do??

Only Chess

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.

c
THE BISHOP GOD

BOSTON

Joined
24 Jan 07
Moves
58368
07 Aug 07

i've seen this a couple of times and the first time i was caught off guard.....the second time i got a cramped position as black.

The moves are 1.e4....e5 2.Qh5.....

i played 2...Nc6 and he played 3.Bc4....

anyone know a line that i can play as black to let white know he shoulda left his king at home?

RS

Under ur ChessBoard!

Joined
12 Feb 07
Moves
2944
07 Aug 07

Originally posted by chessisvanity
i've seen this a couple of times and the first time i was caught off guard.....the second time i got a cramped position as black.

The moves are 1.e4....e5 2.Qh5.....

i played 2...Nc6 and he played 3.Bc4....

anyone know a line that i can play as black to let white know he shoulda left his king at home?
you could always play Qf6 and Bc5 and see how he likes it..

J

back in business

Joined
25 Aug 04
Moves
1264
07 Aug 07

1.e4 e5 2.Qh5? Nc6 3.Bc4 g6 4.Qf3 Nf6 and black is better.

c
THE BISHOP GOD

BOSTON

Joined
24 Jan 07
Moves
58368
07 Aug 07

4.Nf3 now what?......d6?

c
THE BISHOP GOD

BOSTON

Joined
24 Jan 07
Moves
58368
07 Aug 07

Thank you....looks good for me.....1.e4....e5 2.Qh5....Nc6 3.Bc4.....g6!

J

back in business

Joined
25 Aug 04
Moves
1264
07 Aug 07

Originally posted by chessisvanity
4.Nf3 now what?......d6?
Just play 1...d6 okay?

c
THE BISHOP GOD

BOSTON

Joined
24 Jan 07
Moves
58368
07 Aug 07

lol i like e5

S

Joined
14 Jul 06
Moves
20541
07 Aug 07

Originally posted by chessisvanity
Thank you....looks good for me.....1.e4....e5 2.Qh5....Nc6 3.Bc4.....g6!
I used to get this $hit on blitz & you end up playing 2...Nc6, 3...g6, 4...Nf6 with a later ...Bg7 & ...0-0 behind the fianchetto.
Basically white loses the move & gives black a very pleasant, solid opening something like this:

white to move

d
happy

home

Joined
23 Oct 06
Moves
32450
08 Aug 07

Originally posted by chessisvanity
4.Nf3 now what?......d6?
This might very well be a game in progress. Game 3890289.
1. If so, why do you ask for help from other players during a game in progress? Read the site-rules.
2. Why do people comment games in progress?

Regards, 😠

c
THE BISHOP GOD

BOSTON

Joined
24 Jan 07
Moves
58368
08 Aug 07

one...i'm a peice up...
two...i asked for help after 1.e4...e5....2.Qh5......

i didn't ask for help in the game we are playing.....

if you want i will resign and give you the win.

i was only asking for a line to "refute" the 2.Qh5.....

MMM

Joined
05 Apr 04
Moves
37874
08 Aug 07

Originally posted by chessisvanity
if you want i will resign and give you the win.
You can't resign and give dsmfire the win.

System says no

ob

Joined
05 Aug 07
Moves
1638
08 Aug 07

Originally posted by dsmfire
This might very well be a game in progress. Game 3890289.
1. If so, why do you ask for help from other players during a game in progress? Read the site-rules.
2. Why do people comment games in progress?

Regards, 😠
If he asked advice for that game it's clear he didn't follow it 🙂

I actually find this a bit troublesome.Let's say I have a scotch game going,then I can't ask advice about a previous scotch game?

S

Joined
14 Jul 06
Moves
20541
08 Aug 07
1 edit

Originally posted by ouwe belg
If he asked advice for that game it's clear he didn't follow it 🙂

I actually find this a bit troublesome.Let's say I have a scotch game going,then I can't ask advice about a previous scotch game?
I don't see why you couldn't ask about previous moves in a line.
You cannot ask for help in a present or potential future position in a G.I.P though, even if you also played the same line before in a completed game.
That is outside assistance.

ob

Joined
05 Aug 07
Moves
1638
08 Aug 07

Originally posted by Squelchbelch
I don't see why you couldn't ask about previous moves in a line.
You cannot ask for help in a present or potential future position in a G.I.P though, even if you also played the same line before in a completed game.
That is outside assistance.
Yes,I would agree with you.It's only normal,imo.
But the starter of this thread got an angry post for doing so,hence I was wondering what the common policy here is.

c

USA

Joined
22 Dec 05
Moves
13780
10 Aug 07

Originally posted by Squelchbelch
I used to get this $hit on blitz & you end up playing 2...Nc6, 3...g6, 4...Nf6 with a later ...Bg7 & ...0-0 behind the fianchetto.
Basically white loses the move & gives black a very pleasant, solid opening something like this:

white to move
[fen]r1bq1rk1/pppp1pbp/2n2np1/4p3/2B1P3/2N2Q2/PPPPNPPP/R1B1K2R w KQ - 0 7[/fen]
Why fianchetto? It limits the activity of the bishop due to the pawn on e5