What the Queen cannot do...

greenpawn34

Posers and Puzzles

31 May 08

greenpawn34

Joined: 06 May 08
Moves: 43363

31 May 08

An old one from BCM in the 60's.

What is it that the Queen cannot do but every
other piece on the chessboard (including pawns) can?

Not a joke question - this is a fact.

doodinthemood

Joined: 31 May 07
Moves: 696

31 May 08

Be one square away from the opposing king and not give check?

wolfgang59

Quiz Master

RHP Arms

Joined: 09 Jun 07
Moves: 48794

31 May 08

I already PMed GP with that answer - but its not really correct cos the King cannot do that either.

Everything I think of that the Q cannot do the King cannot do also.

🙁

Gastel

B is for bye bye

Joined: 09 Apr 06
Moves: 27526

31 May 08

Be traded for more valuable material. (Although, as I write this, I think it must be wrong, because the king is the most valuable.)

wolfgang59

Quiz Master

RHP Arms

Joined: 09 Jun 07
Moves: 48794

31 May 08

2 edits

Originally posted by greenpawn34
An old one from BCM in the 60's.

What is it that the Queen cannot do but every
other piece on the chessboard (including pawns) can?

Not a joke question - this is a fact.

I have an answer ...

The Queen cannot be moved to cause discovered check. All other pieces can!

🙂

greenpawn34

Joined: 06 May 08
Moves: 43363

31 May 08

1 edit

Why the 6th and 8th ranks?

But you are close enough.

Answer:
The Queen is the only piece that cannot be the moving piece
when you give a discovered check.

Think about it - the opposing King would be in check.

Edit 1 - correct - posted just before I gave the answer.

AThousandYoung

GenX, Time to RISE

tinyurl.com/bdeub4va

Joined: 23 Aug 04
Moves: 27259

01 Jun 08

Originally posted by Gastel
Be traded for more valuable material. (Although, as I write this, I think it must be wrong, because the king is the most valuable.)

Kings cannot be captured.

golfer1

Joined: 19 Sep 06
Moves: 3530

01 Jun 08

Originally posted by AThousandYoung
Kings cannot be captured.

This is about queens, not kings.

curseknight

Joined: 27 Apr 08
Moves: 473

01 Jun 08

Originally posted by golfer1
This is about queens, not kings.

This is about reading, not randomly interjecting.

Gastel

B is for bye bye

Joined: 09 Apr 06
Moves: 27526

01 Jun 08

Originally posted by AThousandYoung
Kings cannot be captured.

And hence are the most valuable. If the a situation even exists where you are going to lose your king, you lose the game.

AThousandYoung

GenX, Time to RISE

tinyurl.com/bdeub4va

Joined: 23 Aug 04
Moves: 27259

02 Jun 08

Originally posted by Gastel
And hence are the most valuable. If the a situation even exists where you are going to lose your king, you lose the game.

If the King cannot be captured, how do you trade for it?

Gastel

B is for bye bye

Joined: 09 Apr 06
Moves: 27526

02 Jun 08

You don't, it is too valuable to trade. I would give you any piece of mine on the board for your king. That's the goal of chess.

eldragonfly

leperchaun messiah

thru a glass onion

Joined: 19 Apr 03
Moves: 16870

06 Jun 08

1 edit

this is a valuable discussion.

thyme

Undutchable

was here

Joined: 23 Jul 07
Moves: 83545

14 Jun 08

1 edit

Very valuable. There are two correct answers.

geepamoogle

Joined: 15 Feb 07
Moves: 667

14 Jun 08

Originally posted by AThousandYoung
If the King cannot be captured, how do you trade for it?

One could argue that checkmate is the inevitable capture of the king on the next move.

Of course, typically a trade is done by one traded piece capturing the other only to be recaptured, and this is impossible between the king and enemy queen. The king cannot remain in check, and if the queen is protected, then the king cannot capture her.

If what is meant by trading a queen for a king is allowing her capture in order to checkmate, then that is better described as a sacrifice..