Originally posted by twhitehead
Well that obviously depends on your definition of 'probability'.
[b]So even if the maths assigns a logical possibility of something in the external world a 0 probability,
The maths doesn't actually assign a probability of 0. It assigns an infinitesimally small probability. But it isn't undefined.
The series I quoted above can we written as a s ...[text shortened]... declaration that it is 'undefined' is similar to claiming that a runner can never finish a race.[/b]
Similarly the probability can be thought of as being open at zero ie it is everything upto but not including zero.
if that probability is an 'infinitesimal' i.e. a probability (NOT probability
density, which isn't a true probability ) of just one value of continuous random variable x,"everything" means, say BOTH value a and value b where a≠b (and it doesn't matter how 'close' a and b are to zero ). But that will be a contradictory probability because, a probability, if it exists for something, cannot have more than one value. Thus if a said 'probability' both equals a and b where a≠b then that indicates it is undefined.
I think the main confusion is that you are dealing with infinities but refusing to accept them. That thinking is what gives people problems with Zenos paradox. Your declaration that it is 'undefined' is similar to claiming that a runner can never finish a race.
No it isn't! Because 1/2 + 1/4 + 1/8 .... is in this case not referring to a
probability nor
probabilities.
Probability has to obey slightly
different rules to avoid certain epistemological contradictions which don't apply to just distances, speeds and time intervals alone without any relation to probability. For example, you can without a contradiction refer to a
logical possibility, NOT to be confused with a
probability, of a time interval between two events being exactly 0 ; no problem! But, as soon as you refer to a
probability of a time interval between two events being exactly 0 when it is also
logically possible for the time interval between two events being exactly 0, NOW you have a problem!