16 Sep '08 20:56>
I realise that the "Genius of Charles Darwin" series finished weeks ago but the "Darwin" thread it prompted is still winding its pointless way so I thought I'd start another.
I watched the series hoping to see an explanation of the theory for the layman (it is a remarkably simple theory considering its impact: no maths required and if explained well the whole thing becomes blindingly obvious) and/or a biography of the man himself. What we got was neither. What we got was another polemic against religion. Evidence for and explanation of evolution was scant. Dawkins was preaching to the converted and maybe a narrow band of undecideds. My wife is a 'default' christian: goes to church once a month but does not know anything really about the religion. I wanted this series to be for her but I am too embarrassed to encourage her to watch it.
As you probably know, I agree with most of what Dawkins says. His books are far better. Well written, clear and informative but on tellyI find him to be a disappointment.
Is Dawkins doing more harm than good? Was a fine opportunity to educate and inform thrown away? What do you guys think?
--- Penguin.
I watched the series hoping to see an explanation of the theory for the layman (it is a remarkably simple theory considering its impact: no maths required and if explained well the whole thing becomes blindingly obvious) and/or a biography of the man himself. What we got was neither. What we got was another polemic against religion. Evidence for and explanation of evolution was scant. Dawkins was preaching to the converted and maybe a narrow band of undecideds. My wife is a 'default' christian: goes to church once a month but does not know anything really about the religion. I wanted this series to be for her but I am too embarrassed to encourage her to watch it.
As you probably know, I agree with most of what Dawkins says. His books are far better. Well written, clear and informative but on tellyI find him to be a disappointment.
Is Dawkins doing more harm than good? Was a fine opportunity to educate and inform thrown away? What do you guys think?
--- Penguin.