Originally posted by eatmybishop
no, you're right, how can anyone disagree with the points you raised; however, your original point was without the knowledge we have aquired we would not have survived....
i disagree with you on that point, once again, i am saying we do not need the knowledge we have aquired in order to have survived for this long... prove to me if we were still livin ...[text shortened]... african tribes have not changed their lifestyle for thousands of years but still remain today)
The african tribespeople are as intelligent as any 'developed world' citizen. their intelligence and their specific knowledge enables them to survive. The difference between me (who would probably be dead in a week) and them is their knowledge.
Without our intelligence, we would not have learnt to make tools such as spears, bows and traps to help our hunting, knives to skin our prey for clothes, fire to cook our prey and for warmth. We would not have been able to migrate out of africa, since we would not have been able to handle the colder climate.
Without our intelligence, we would be an african omnivore, with a total population in the tens or hundreds of thousands, no more. Quite possibly, we would have been wiped out by another species since it is really only our intelligence that allows us to compete.
Certainly we, as a species but without our intelligence, would be far less able to cope with catastrophic events such as meteorite strikes, earthquakes, tsunamis, global glimate change and other natural disasters (I accept that we are probably the cause of one such event at the moment but we are also the species best able to cope with it)
We are also the only species in the history of the planet with the potential to get ourselve off this single rock and become fully space-faring, the only true long term survival option.
Looking again at your post to which I am replying, I think I have digressed. It seems your gripe is with our knowledge rather than our intelligence. However, it is our intelligence that is inate, not our knowledge. Whether an individual would survive in the wild depends on what knowledge that individual has turned their intelligence to acquiring. And the future long-term survival of the species is heavily dependant on the scientific knowledge we have gained through the centuries, as well as our intelligence.
--- Penguin.