Originally posted by coquette
the marks on the ruler do not make the reality
time is the marks on the ruler
the reality is matter and motion
just as a ruler is marked in miles (or meters), so time is marked in days and weeks and years
the years don't "exist"
time is the marks on the ruler
if that is true (metaphorically), then time does exists! -it exists as the marks on 'the ruler'!
I have seen this very type logical error being made countless times by people that claim that doesn't exists; they say time is X AND say times does not exist when you cannot have it both ways.
If time
is X (whatever X is) then that
is what time is therefore time
does exist because time exists as X!
But I haven't come across “ time is the marks on the ruler” before. Usually, and more typically, I have heard of time being dismissed as “just a series of events” and 'therefore' time doesn't exist.
But this is the same kind of logical flaw for if time literally
is “just a series of events” and nothing more then, logically, that
is what time is therefore time
does exist because it exists as “just a series of events”!
(although I never thought it makes much sense to say time is
just a series of events anyway because “a
series of events” requires a '
series' but a '
series' implies 'before and after' which implies some kind of dimension and direction which surely, in this particular context, implies time! i.e. it implies the very thing as that 'time-denier' dismisses as nothing more than “just a series of events”! I don't think that's logically consistent)