Go back
Journey to the centre of the Earth.

Journey to the centre of the Earth.

Science

m

Joined
08 Nov 07
Moves
39045
Clock
01 Apr 12
Vote Up
Vote Down

Could it be done?

http://www.virginvolcanic.com/

googlefudge

Joined
31 May 06
Moves
1795
Clock
01 Apr 12
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by murphius
Could it be done?

http://www.virginvolcanic.com/
Only on April 1st.

h

Joined
06 Mar 12
Moves
642
Clock
01 Apr 12
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by murphius
Could it be done?

http://www.virginvolcanic.com/
Its a big joke. It is a pure fantasy only in part ( there are several reasons ) because no known material can hold back the huge pressures and temperatures to stop a capsule imploding. Not even solid diamond would be sufficient. I have speculated that, with extreme difficulty, it might be possible to send an unmanned probe with no air-gaps in it to implode a short distance below the Earth's crust and briefly swim very slowly ( magma has high viscosity ) in the magma and send some meaningful data back to the surface. But a manned vehicle to the core of the Earth will always be pure fantasy.

W
Pusher of wood

Los Gatos, CA

Joined
03 Mar 11
Moves
5760
Clock
03 Apr 12
Vote Up
Vote Down

I love one of the comments made at that URL: "Brings new meaning to sacrificing a virgin to the volcano!"

Anyway, it seems like the goal of the project is far less ambitious than travelling to the core of the earth. Rather, just probing inside a volcano. It seems like that's a little more realistic.

googlefudge

Joined
31 May 06
Moves
1795
Clock
04 Apr 12
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by WoodPush
I love one of the comments made at that URL: "Brings new meaning to sacrificing a virgin to the volcano!"

Anyway, it seems like the goal of the project is far less ambitious than travelling to the core of the earth. Rather, just probing inside a volcano. It seems like that's a little more realistic.
Heh, funny comment.


Um... no the goal of the project is to be an April fools joke.

None of it is remotely realistic.

W
Pusher of wood

Los Gatos, CA

Joined
03 Mar 11
Moves
5760
Clock
06 Apr 12
Vote Up
Vote Down

And the joke lives on 🙂

t

Joined
28 Dec 11
Moves
16268
Clock
07 Apr 12
Vote Up
Vote Down

what if there was a hole right through the earth and you jump in it would you fall out of the hole?

googlefudge

Joined
31 May 06
Moves
1795
Clock
07 Apr 12
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by tim88
what if there was a hole right through the earth and you jump in it would you fall out of the hole?
If there was a tunnel straight through the centre of the earth.
And that tunnel contained a vacuum (so there was no air resistance).
Then if you jumped into it you would accelerate towards the centre of the earth until you
reached the very centre and then you would decelerate all the way back up the other side
until you reached the same hight above the geodesy as you started from.

At which point you would stop. (and then fall back again assuming you didn't grab hold of
anything.)

If there was air resistance then you would be slowed down and just get stuck in the core.

t

Joined
28 Dec 11
Moves
16268
Clock
11 Apr 12
Vote Up
Vote Down

INTERESTING!

W
Pusher of wood

Los Gatos, CA

Joined
03 Mar 11
Moves
5760
Clock
16 Apr 12
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by googlefudge
If there was a tunnel straight through the centre of the earth.
And that tunnel contained a vacuum (so there was no air resistance).
Then if you jumped into it you would accelerate towards the centre of the earth until you
reached the very centre and then you would decelerate all the way back up the other side
until you reached the same hight above .)

If there was air resistance then you would be slowed down and just get stuck in the core.
Even in a vacuum, you'd eventually settle in the core.

You'd keep smacking into the hole's walls, as the earth would keep rotating, and you of course wouldn't along with it. You'd eventually lose enough energy to end up in the core, regardless.

K

Germany

Joined
27 Oct 08
Moves
3118
Clock
16 Apr 12
Vote Up
Vote Down

More realistically, if there was such a hole it would get filled up quite rapidly.

W
Pusher of wood

Los Gatos, CA

Joined
03 Mar 11
Moves
5760
Clock
16 Apr 12
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by KazetNagorra
More realistically, if there was such a hole it would get filled up quite rapidly.
I almost made the same comment, but then again having a nice tunnel through the earth isn't so realistic to begin with, so I decided to forgo that 🙂

a

Joined
08 Oct 06
Moves
24000
Clock
16 Apr 12
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by WoodPush
as the earth would keep rotating, and you of course wouldn't along with it. [/b]
Why not?

W
Pusher of wood

Los Gatos, CA

Joined
03 Mar 11
Moves
5760
Clock
16 Apr 12
2 edits
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by amolv06
Why not?
Newton's first and second laws.

The only force acting on you would be gravity, which would accelerate you to the center of the planet. So I'll ask back to you, what force, (remember you're in a vacuum) would propel you to keep you in pace with the earth's rotation?

a

Joined
08 Oct 06
Moves
24000
Clock
16 Apr 12
Vote Up
Vote Down

The centripetal force of gravity. Angular momentum would have to be conserved, right?

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.