Please turn on javascript in your browser to play chess.
Site Ideas Forum

Site Ideas Forum

  1. Standard member rhb
    Ginger Scum
    20 Sep '06 21:25
    For the change announced by Russ in this thread:

    threadid=52571

    Thread 52571

    This will only really add value to the site if everyones Rec counters are reset to Zero - otherwise Rec totals per user remain meaningless as a measure of their meaningful contribution to the forums.
  2. Standard member Red Night
    RHP Prophet
    20 Sep '06 21:27
    Originally posted by rhb
    For the change announced by Russ in this thread:

    threadid=52571

    Thread 52571

    This will only really add value to the site if everyones Rec counters are reset to Zero - otherwise Rec totals per user remain meaningless as a measure of their meaningful contribution to the forums.
    Great point!!
  3. Standard member rhb
    Ginger Scum
    20 Sep '06 21:34
    Originally posted by Red Night
    Great point!!
    If you like it, Rec it then.
  4. Standard member Red Night
    RHP Prophet
    20 Sep '06 21:40
    Originally posted by rhb
    If you like it, Rec it then.
    Done.
  5. 20 Sep '06 21:47
    Originally posted by rhb
    For the change announced by Russ in this thread:

    threadid=52571

    Thread 52571

    This will only really add value to the site if everyones Rec counters are reset to Zero - otherwise Rec totals per user remain meaningless as a measure of their meaningful contribution to the forums.
    Or better even, get rid of the total wreck counter altogether.
  6. Subscriber Suzianne
    Misfit Queen
    21 Sep '06 17:01
    Originally posted by rhb
    For the change announced by Russ in this thread:

    threadid=52571

    Thread 52571

    This will only really add value to the site if everyones Rec counters are reset to Zero - otherwise Rec totals per user remain meaningless as a measure of their meaningful contribution to the forums.
    "As a measure of their meaningful contribution to the forums", rec totals were meaningless before and they'll still be meaningless, because people did and will still rec the nasty, mean-spirited, insulting posts.

    Only now, with recs at a premium, only the nastiest and meanest posts will get recced, giving even more incentive to be even nastier and meaner than before.

    Maybe now, though, those with the most recs will be ostracized and held up as the meanest and nastiest posters.

    Hmmm, no way, they'll still be seen as heroes.


    I only hope I'm wrong.
  7. Standard member IM4Y2NV
    Dadohalic
    21 Sep '06 17:04
    Originally posted by Suzianne
    "As a measure of their meaningful contribution to the forums", rec totals were meaningless before and they'll still be meaningless, because people did and will still rec the nasty, mean-spirited, insulting posts.

    Only now, with recs at a premium, only the nastiest and meanest posts will get recced, giving even more incentive to be even nastier and meaner ...[text shortened]... s.

    Hmmm, no way, they'll still be seen as heroes.


    I only hope I'm wrong.
    I beg to differ 5 rec's already and not a nasty word in the whole thread.

    Thread 52603
  8. 21 Sep '06 17:05
    Originally posted by Suzianne
    Hmmm, no way, they'll still be seen as heroes.
    Did anyone ever see anyone as a hero because of their wreck number?
  9. Subscriber Suzianne
    Misfit Queen
    21 Sep '06 17:07
    Originally posted by IM4Y2NV
    I beg to differ 5 rec's already and not a nasty word in the whole thread.

    Thread 52603
    Come on. If there was *one* place on this site where nastiness was not held in high esteem, where the rec system actually worked, it was the Site Ideas forum. People tended to rec ideas they agree with, not the nasty posts.
  10. Subscriber Suzianne
    Misfit Queen
    21 Sep '06 17:09 / 1 edit
    Originally posted by Nordlys
    Did anyone ever see anyone as a hero because of their wreck number?
    They weren't seen as heroes because of their rec number, they were seen as heroes because they were the nastiest posters. And as such, happened to get the most recs. Don't put the effect before the cause.

    Edit: Hmmm, looking over my post, I see where I could give the impression I thought this. Bad composition on my part.
  11. 21 Sep '06 17:12
    Originally posted by Suzianne
    They weren't seen as heroes because of their rec number, they were seen as heroes because they were the nastiest posters. And as such, happened to get the most recs. Don't put the effect before the cause.
    If that's the case, why are you so much against the wreck system?
  12. Subscriber Suzianne
    Misfit Queen
    21 Sep '06 17:15
    Originally posted by Nordlys
    If that's the case, why are you so much against the wreck system?
    Probably because it quantifies the effect. And it will still do so, only the total number of recs will be less over the same time period.
  13. 21 Sep '06 19:51
    Originally posted by Suzianne
    They weren't seen as heroes because of their rec number, they were seen as heroes because they were the nastiest posters.
    Are you talking about Ivanhoe?
  14. Standard member leisurelysloth
    Man of Steel
    21 Sep '06 20:03
    Originally posted by Suzianne
    Maybe now, though, those with the most recs will be ostracized and held up as the meanest and nastiest posters....
    Yeah. Like this character! User 1
  15. Standard member rhb
    Ginger Scum
    23 Sep '06 16:45
    I didn't think this idea would be taken up so quickly!

    As it was such a good idea, I hope someone will please take my new rec virginity for it.