Go back
Can laws be broken?

Can laws be broken?

Spirituality

divegeester
watching in dismay

STARMERGEDDON

Joined
16 Feb 08
Moves
120597
Clock
21 Oct 10
Vote Up
Vote Down

Laws are only absolutes if there is no higher law e.g the law* of gravity is only seen in action if there is no higher force opposing that law.

E.g when a father lifts his baby from it's cot, the law of gravity is not broken, it is merely temporarily superseded by the strength of the parent. However to a being not familiar with the concept of a "parent" the act would appear as though a law had been broken.

To assume that what may be viewed as "miracles" is either impossible or against the "laws" of physics, is restricting ourselves from a universe of possibilities and exploration both temporal and spiritual.



*http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Newton's_law_of_universal_gravitation

l

Milton Keynes, UK

Joined
28 Jul 04
Moves
81605
Clock
21 Oct 10
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by divegeester
Laws are only absolutes if there is no higher law e.g the law* of gravity is only seen in action if there is no higher force opposing that law.

E.g when a father lifts his baby from it's cot, the law of gravity is not broken, it is merely temporarily superseded by the strength of the parent. However to a being not familiar with the concept of a "pa nd spiritual.



*http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Newton's_law_of_universal_gravitation
Not sure what you are trying to say here. Laws cannot be broken. If there is something that appears to be a miracle because of something undiscovered in physics, then it just means that there are some unknown laws (which also cannot be broken). We just have yet to discover them. 😛

P
Upward Spiral

Halfway

Joined
02 Aug 04
Moves
8702
Clock
21 Oct 10
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by divegeester
Laws are only absolutes if there is no higher law e.g the law* of gravity is only seen in action if there is no higher force opposing that law.

E.g when a father lifts his baby from it's cot, the law of gravity is not broken, it is merely temporarily superseded by the strength of the parent. However to a being not familiar with the concept of a "pa ...[text shortened]... nd spiritual.



*http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Newton's_law_of_universal_gravitation
Is that a reason to believe miracles can happen or that supposed miracles are simply not that miraculous?

I think most atheists would agree that perceived miracles are actually natural phenomena being misinterpreted (or imagined) by the viewer.

I may be missing your point, though, sorry.

duecer
anybody seen my

underpants??

Joined
01 Sep 06
Moves
56453
Clock
21 Oct 10
Vote Up
Vote Down

laws are meant to broken😠

http://www.foxcreekleather.com/images/brando.jpg

twhitehead

Cape Town

Joined
14 Apr 05
Moves
52945
Clock
21 Oct 10
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by divegeester
Laws are only absolutes if there is no higher law e.g the law* of gravity is only seen in action if there is no higher force opposing that law.
In line with what lausey has said, laws cannot be broken by definition. The definition of "Law" is "a rule that is never violated". If a violation occurs then what we thought was a law is in fact not a law.

E.g when a father lifts his baby from it's cot, the law of gravity is not broken, it is merely temporarily superseded by the strength of the parent. However to a being not familiar with the concept of a "parent" the act would appear as though a law had been broken.
I disagree with your interpretation here. The law of gravity only states that a force will be applied. It does not in any way require actual movement. The laws of motion require movement based on the total force applied. When a father lifts his baby from its cot, all the laws are in action and are seen to operate to perfection.

For some people, a miracle does not necessarily violate the laws of physics. It may be something improbable (whether this violates the laws of physics is up for discussion), or merely something beneficial.

What I tend to object to is the term 'supernatural' which is used in an attempt to avoid being challenged by the laws of physics. But it is actually somewhat incoherent once you think about it. For some people, a miracle is supernatural (and thus incoherent).

h

Joined
06 May 10
Moves
4146
Clock
21 Oct 10
Vote Up
Vote Down

right...gravity is a force..the force exerted by the father simply overcomes that force of gravity. If the baby was not "lifted" when the force was applied...that would have broken a"law"

F

Joined
11 Nov 05
Moves
43938
Clock
22 Oct 10
Vote Up
Vote Down

In Sweden the weather will be snowy, the winter is coming, and the roads will be icy and slippery.

I would love to see a commersial ad, something like this:

"Holy tires for sale!
Blessed by the bishop for higher friction!
Garanteed to prevent accidents for baptized drivers!"

And this would be possible if miracles are possible. They are not possible according to known science. Therefore we can safely laugh at the proposed ad above.

t

Joined
24 Sep 10
Moves
965
Clock
23 Oct 10
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by FabianFnas
In Sweden the weather will be snowy, the winter is coming, and the roads will be icy and slippery.

I would love to see a commersial ad, something like this:

"Holy tires for sale!
Blessed by the bishop for higher friction!
Garanteed to prevent accidents for baptized drivers!"

And this would be possible if miracles are possible. They are not possible according to known science. Therefore we can safely laugh at the proposed ad above.
http://www.spirituality.com/dt/toc_sh.jhtml

100 pages of them for you all to read

t

Joined
24 Sep 10
Moves
965
Clock
23 Oct 10
Vote Up
Vote Down

Chapter 18

Fruitage


These are the first 12 testimonies, from this wonderful book, that many would call a miracle.

RHEUMATISM HEALED
ASTIGMATISM AND HERNIA HEALED
SUBSTANCE OF LUNGS RESTORED
FIBROID TUMOR HEALED IN A FEW DAYS
SPINAL TROUBLE AND INDIGESTION HEALED
A CASE OF MENTAL SURGERY
CATARACT QUICKLY CURED
VALVULAR HEART DISEASE HEALED
THE TRUE PHYSICIAN FOUND
CANCER AND CONSUMPTION HEALED
A REMARKABLE CASE
INTENSE SUFFERING OVERCOME

F

Joined
11 Nov 05
Moves
43938
Clock
23 Oct 10
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by tacoandlettuce
http://www.spirituality.com/dt/toc_sh.jhtml

100 pages of them for you all to read
You mean, seriously, that tires can be made to do its job more effective if it is blessed by the bishop?

Wow, why isn't this tried before?

t

Joined
24 Sep 10
Moves
965
Clock
23 Oct 10
Vote Up
Vote Down

Why do you desire not to gain true understanding to your immeasurable intelligence? It's very clear you do not.

F

Joined
11 Nov 05
Moves
43938
Clock
23 Oct 10
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by tacoandlettuce
Why do you desire not to gain true understanding to your immeasurable intelligence? It's very clear you do not.
It seem you do think it is indeed possible to enhance friction by the technique of blessing!
Is there any scientific measure of friction made to show this blesas-effect?

t

Joined
24 Sep 10
Moves
965
Clock
23 Oct 10
Vote Up
Vote Down

And I am being called a troll.

F

Joined
11 Nov 05
Moves
43938
Clock
23 Oct 10
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by tacoandlettuce
And I am being called a troll.
You evade the question. Therefore I think that you feel painted against a wall, with a sensed no way out of the situation.

This mean that you agree to my point, that there is no way to religiously alter the laws of science, but just don't want to admit it.

Okay, end of story.

If you still avoid the question, then I am forced to start a new thread just in this matter in order to show that there is no religious power to chance the natural laws of science, i.e. miracles are impossible.

josephw
A fun title

Scoffer Mocker

Joined
27 Sep 06
Moves
9958
Clock
24 Oct 10
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by divegeester
Laws are only absolutes if there is no higher law e.g the law* of gravity is only seen in action if there is no higher force opposing that law.

E.g when a father lifts his baby from it's cot, the law of gravity is not broken, it is merely temporarily superseded by the strength of the parent. However to a being not familiar with the concept of a "pa ...[text shortened]... nd spiritual.



*http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Newton's_law_of_universal_gravitation
God created the universe and all the laws that govern it.

A miracle happens when God does the impossible.

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.