11 Dec '07 04:36>1 edit
Disclaimer: I am not a Christian
There are a lot of threads debating whether the metaphysics of Christianity is true / plausible etc. But let's leave those questions aside here and discuss whether a widespread belief in Christianity enhances a society, or has the opposite effect, or no effect at all.
The first thing to get out of the way is that we can acknowledge that, historically, terrible deeds have been done in the name of Christianity - unjust wars have been fought (certain of the Crusades), people tortured (the various Inquisitions, but particularly the Spanish) - and move on. As far as I know, there is nothing in the teachings of Jesus, Paul and so on that condones unjust war or torture, so we can consider these examples of Christianity's being hijacked.
The second thing to get out of the way is fundamentalism - fundamentalists tend to re-introduce the kind of small-minded thinking that Jesus criticised the Pharisees for. It also imports a lot of Old Testament stuff that Christianity essentially renders obsolete. The idea of a vengeful God is replaced by the idea of a loving God and so on. It also imports stuff like the Genesis story of creation and insists on its literal truth. Yes, this is Christianity as practiced by some, and is probably not socially useful, but again we can acknowledge that and move on. What I'm after here is whether Christianity at its best is socially useful or not.
It seems to me that this sort of belief can help people psychologically by making them feel 'someone' is looking out for them, so they are less likely to despair when all is going wrong.
Also, the notion of an afterlife that can be spent in heaven or hell, depending on one's actions here on earth, provides strong reasons to behave ethically for someone with these beliefs. Society is better when people behave ethically toward each other.
Christian teaching even has something to say about what it is to behave ethically ('Do unto others...", "Love one another..." ). A society comprised of people who follow these maxims would be pretty good to live in, I would think. And there's nothing stopping people from following these maxims, even if they believe that Christian metaphysics is true. Of course, there is the question of whether they have a reason to so act, but that's a question for another time.
There are a lot of threads debating whether the metaphysics of Christianity is true / plausible etc. But let's leave those questions aside here and discuss whether a widespread belief in Christianity enhances a society, or has the opposite effect, or no effect at all.
The first thing to get out of the way is that we can acknowledge that, historically, terrible deeds have been done in the name of Christianity - unjust wars have been fought (certain of the Crusades), people tortured (the various Inquisitions, but particularly the Spanish) - and move on. As far as I know, there is nothing in the teachings of Jesus, Paul and so on that condones unjust war or torture, so we can consider these examples of Christianity's being hijacked.
The second thing to get out of the way is fundamentalism - fundamentalists tend to re-introduce the kind of small-minded thinking that Jesus criticised the Pharisees for. It also imports a lot of Old Testament stuff that Christianity essentially renders obsolete. The idea of a vengeful God is replaced by the idea of a loving God and so on. It also imports stuff like the Genesis story of creation and insists on its literal truth. Yes, this is Christianity as practiced by some, and is probably not socially useful, but again we can acknowledge that and move on. What I'm after here is whether Christianity at its best is socially useful or not.
It seems to me that this sort of belief can help people psychologically by making them feel 'someone' is looking out for them, so they are less likely to despair when all is going wrong.
Also, the notion of an afterlife that can be spent in heaven or hell, depending on one's actions here on earth, provides strong reasons to behave ethically for someone with these beliefs. Society is better when people behave ethically toward each other.
Christian teaching even has something to say about what it is to behave ethically ('Do unto others...", "Love one another..." ). A society comprised of people who follow these maxims would be pretty good to live in, I would think. And there's nothing stopping people from following these maxims, even if they believe that Christian metaphysics is true. Of course, there is the question of whether they have a reason to so act, but that's a question for another time.