24 Aug '17 14:14>
Is evil real and something to be avoided, or merely a construct of the human mind?
Originally posted by @dj2beckerCan't it be both? Being real doesn't mean we grasp it for what it really is, so we ponder it, it's reality, and what are the ramifications?
Is evil real and something to be avoided, or merely a construct of the human mind?
Originally posted by @kellyjayIf evil is real I wonder how atheism would account for its existence.
Can't it be both? Being real doesn't mean we grasp it for what it really is, so we ponder it, it's reality, and what are the ramifications?
Originally posted by @kellyjayWhat is evil for you may not be for me, and vice versa. This is disturbing for some.
Can't it be both? Being real doesn't mean we grasp it for what it really is, so we ponder it, it's reality, and what are the ramifications?
Originally posted by @apathistIs evil real or a construct of the mind?
What is evil for you may not be for me, and vice versa. This is disturbing for some.
Originally posted by @apathistMy point evil could be both, something very real that doesn't need us to define it, and something we attempt to grasp or ignore to our own peril.
What is evil for you may not be for me, and vice versa. This is disturbing for some.
Originally posted by @kellyjayEvil is subjective. My evil may not be yours. But I care about our species surviving, and then evil becomes clear.
My point evil could be both, something very real that doesn't need us to define it, and something we attempt to grasp or ignore to our own peril.
Originally posted by @kellyjayI don't disagree. In reality we don't get much hindsight though. Evil opposes our growth.
My point evil could be both, something very real that doesn't need us to define it, and something we attempt to grasp or ignore to our own peril.
Originally posted by @dj2beckerThe word "evil" refers to certain kinds of morally unsound behaviour. It is a human (i.e. mundane) social construct, not a supernatural one, even if many humans do superimpose such notions onto the concept in their efforts to make sense of the human condition.
Is evil real or a construct of the mind?
Originally posted by @sonshipAnd who has dismissed evil as completely imagined? Which thread was that on sonship?
Dismissing evil as completely imagined is not an answer to the problem.
Originally posted by @sonshipMental hospitals also contain people who have done things that are perceived as "evil" but the diminished responsibility of those inmates may well explain why their actions do not warrant the descriptor "evil". The criminal justice system is often able to deal with this.
Mental hospitals contain people with false guilt.
Originally posted by @dj2beckerAtheism is nothing more than being unconvinced that gods exist. It is silent on everything else, including opinions on morality.
If evil is real I wonder how atheism would account for its existence.