Originally posted by bbarr
Right. We may focus LJ's point by asking whether the Fall itself was logically necessary. I see no contradiction in supposing that humans could have simply continued to live in harmony with God's will. If they freely did so pre-Fall, then there is a logically possible world where they continued to freely do so; where nobody messed up. But if that is right, the ...[text shortened]... vere harms. But would these harms have to be as ubiquitous as they are in the actual world?
Thanks for the thoughtful post, bbarr.
Here's what I can muster, given all the particulars and whatever limitations my eloquence suffers.
The GAFE wishes God's attributes to never be restrained, no matter what the reaction of man.
If man rejects, refuses and otherwise supplants His system in favor of a system without intrinsic good, God is expected to mitigate (what? the most egregious? the most physically/psychologically painful?) the damages.
It begs the question, of course: why those things?
Why draw the line on some of the suffering, and not all of it?
If man knowingly and willfully options for 'Good and Evil' instead of 'Lives,' why are we to expect God to act as though the decision was never made?
If He doesn't require suffering in order to see the greater good (ala pre-Fall), why was it allowed?
Because this--- post-Fall, sans God's rulership of the planet--- is what man chose.
The question posed was 'does man need God to be good?'
Satan denies the need for God.
Human history says something different.
His plan for pre-Fall is different than His plan for post-Fall, wherein His attributes are muted.
Yet He continues to work with the material created: He leaves the choice to man.
That's really the answer, too.
You paint a picture of a better-equipped creature, which looks mysteriously like the Christian... the same one who enters back into God's system, regardless of the environment.
Put simply, we can't reasonably expect God to put forth the same benefits of His character when we are (in essence) His enemy, as He would put forth toward His friends.