Go back
I shall explain.

I shall explain.

Spirituality


When I ask someone......

What is it that makes a religion false?

And.....

What is it that makes religion true?

I am asking them to list the principles or truisms or qualities that make religion true or false.

The answer has nothing to do with subjective mental speculation or imagination, but has everything to do with objective truth.

This truth has been taught generation after generation and it never changes with time, because it is dealing with eternal absolute truth.

This could be the same question but a different subject, such as...........What rules and qualities are necessary when building a house.

Do you think the answer is subjective and therefore relies on good speculation and imagination.

NO..................but instead there is an authority that stipulates all manner of rules and regulations{and everyone is glad to comply]

And the same is for religion and that Authority is the Vedic teachings.

And there is no other authority.


Originally posted by Dasa
When I ask someone......

What is it that makes a religion false?

And.....

What is it that makes religion true?

I am asking them to list the principles or truisms or qualities that make religion true or false.

The answer has nothing to do with subjective mental speculation or imagination, but has everything to do with objective truth.

This tr ...[text shortened]... e is for religion and that Authority is the Vedic teachings.

And there is no other authority.
When they saw Him, they worshiped Him; but some were doubtful. And Jesus came up and spoke to them, saying, "All authority has been given to Me in heaven and on earth. "Go therefore and make disciples of all the nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit,…

(Matthew 28:17-19)


Originally posted by Dasa
I am asking them to list the principles or truisms or qualities that make religion true or false. The answer has nothing to do with subjective mental speculation or imagination, but has everything to do with objective truth.
I disagree. The affiliation to a particular religion is subjective because the evidence necessary to establish a so-called "objective truth" is unavailable or at least is not of a nature that allows consensus and common perspective. As for "the principles or truisms or qualities that make religion true or false", these will depend on the religion of the person answering your question.


Originally posted by Dasa
This truth has been taught generation after generation and it never changes with time, because it is dealing with eternal absolute truth.
The same can be claimed by adherents of literally hundreds of religions in competition with yours.

1 edit


Originally posted by Dasa
When I ask someone......

Ask one point at a time (or per thread)
then we can have an honest discussion.


Originally posted by Dasa
When I ask someone......

What is it that makes a religion false?

And.....

What is it that makes religion true?

I am asking them to list the principles or truisms or qualities that make religion true or false.

The answer has nothing to do with subjective mental speculation or imagination, but has everything to do with objective truth.

This tr ...[text shortened]... e is for religion and that Authority is the Vedic teachings.

And there is no other authority.
so when you ask what makes a religion false, you are really already answering yourself in your mind with the only answer you would accept.


that's dishonest.


-Removed-
Looks to me like your universe and his universe are the same sizes.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Dasa
When I ask someone......

What is it that makes a religion false?

And.....

What is it that makes religion true?

I am asking them to list the principles or truisms or qualities that make religion true or false.

The answer has nothing to do with subjective mental speculation or imagination, but has everything to do with objective truth.

This tr ...[text shortened]... e is for religion and that Authority is the Vedic teachings.

And there is no other authority.
http://hinduism.about.com/cs/vedasvedanta/a/aa120103a.htm

The Mother of All Scriptures

"Although the Vedas are seldom read or understood today, even by the devout, they no doubt form the bedrock of the universal religion or “Sanatana Dharma” that all Hindus follow. The Vedas have guided our religious direction for ages and will continue to do so for generations to come. And they will forever remain the most comprehensive and universal of all ancient scriptures."


Interesting. "Seldom read or understood" yet "remain the most comprehensive and universal of all ancient scriptures".

Seems to me that if the Veda's were actually what you claim them to be they would occupy a place in literature with global publication in most languages as is the Bible. I think Vishnu must have fallen asleep at the wheel and veered off the path. If Vishnu thinks he's the saviour he better get busy getting his word out like his competitor the God of the Bible. Souls are at stake here Dasa. Just sayin'. 😉

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Dasa
When I ask someone......

What is it that makes a religion false?

And.....

What is it that makes religion true?

I am asking them to list the principles or truisms or qualities that make religion true or false.

The answer has nothing to do with subjective mental speculation or imagination, but has everything to do with objective truth.

This tr ...[text shortened]... e is for religion and that Authority is the Vedic teachings.

And there is no other authority.
The answer has nothing to do with subjective mental speculation or imagination, but has everything to do with objective truth.
Demonstrate then that the Veda's provide the basis for "true" religion. Incidentally you have to provide a compelling argument that there is a God at all, and you have to show that the Vedas contain the correct description of his nature.

1 edit

Originally posted by DeepThought
The answer has nothing to do with subjective mental speculation or imagination, but has everything to do with objective truth.
Demonstrate then that the Veda's provide the basis for "true" religion. Incidentally you have to provide a compelling argument that there is a God at all, and you have to show that the Vedas contain the correct description of his nature.
Go and purchase the 18 volume Srimad Bhagavatam translated by His Divine Grace Srila Prabhupada.

When you have read the entire collection you will without doubt have your answer.

You don't think you will be just given the answer without some effort on your part.

This shall test your sincerity.


Originally posted by josephw
http://hinduism.about.com/cs/vedasvedanta/a/aa120103a.htm

[b]The Mother of All Scriptures

"Although the Vedas are seldom read or understood today, even by the devout, they no doubt form the bedrock of the universal religion or “Sanatana Dharma” that all Hindus follow. The Vedas have guided our religious direction for ages and will continue to do so for ...[text shortened]... word out like his competitor the God of the Bible. Souls are at stake here Dasa. Just sayin'. 😉
They are seldom read because most people are uneducated and ignorant.


Originally posted by FMF
The same can be claimed by adherents of literally hundreds of religions in competition with yours.
No


Originally posted by Zahlanzi
so when you ask what makes a religion false, you are really already answering yourself in your mind with the only answer you would accept.


that's dishonest.
Incorrect

Vote Up
Vote Down

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.